Category: politics

  • ‘Screwing it up’: HMRC’s £14m error lets tax avoidance specialist off the hook

    Spread the love

    Original article by Ed Siddons republished from TBIJ under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.

    Basic mistake was made in pursuit of fine against man thought to have cost the exchequer £1bn in lost revenue

    HMRC squandered the chance to hold a notorious promoter of tax avoidance schemes to account after making a “rudimentary” error at tribunal, new documents reveal.

    According to a recently published tax tribunal judgement, the UK tax authority was attempting to bring a £14m penalty against Paul Baxendale-Walker, a former lawyer and tax adviser. HMRC estimates his schemes to have cost the exchequer some £1bn in lost taxes according to a separate court filing.

    Baxendale-Walker denied a “false collection of allegations” put to him by TBIJ, and said the £14m penalty was “a fiction … conjured” by HMRC.

    The judgement raises questions about HMRC’s handling of the promoters of tax avoidance schemes at a time when tax has become a battleground in the forthcoming general election.

    ‘There’s a lack of battlefield command within HMRC’

    HMRC has enjoyed some substantial victories in recent years, including a £650m windfall and fraud conviction against former F1 mogul Bernie Ecclestone, and a landmark £615m deferred prosecution agreement with the owner of Ladbrokes and Coral. But experts suggest it has failed to adequately hold enablers of tax dodging to account.

    “This is screwing it up 101,” said Ray McCann, the former president of the Chartered Institute of Taxation and a senior HMRC investigator of more than 30 years. “I’m completely mystified as to why [HMRC] did what they did [… it appears] there’s a lack of battlefield command within HMRC.”

    Baxendale-Walker, 60, gained notoriety after designing a number of tax avoidance schemes in the 1990s and 2000s that were later found not to be legal.

    Court documents filed in a separate case in the United States cite HMRC estimates that his schemes cost the tax authority over £1bn in total. Baxendale-Walker disputed this figure to TBIJ, but did not provide evidence to support his claim. “He’s caused carnage,” said McCann.

    HMRC was attempting to bring a penalty based on an information notice it obtained at tribunal in 2022, to force Baxendale-Walker to hand over documents to the authority. Baxendale-Walker told TBIJ that he did not have the documents to begin with, and HMRC said it would not comment on individual cases.

    HMRC agreed to an extension requested by Baxendale-Walker, but in doing so made one of two mistakes, both of which involved missing a deadline for imposing a penalty.

    The Upper Tribunal judge found that it did not matter which mistake HMRC had made, it had invalidated the £14m penalty regardless.

    The judge struck out the proposed £14m fine in its entirety in a judgement handed down on 28 July 2023, which was made public this month.

    McCann said: “When I was in [HMRC], I would never in a million years have deviated from what a tribunal had authorised because it always goes wrong. […] Now the penalty is history because [HMRC] screwed it up.”

    Over the past two decades, Baxendale-Walker has been subject to various civil court cases, professional sanctions and criminal charges.

    He was struck off as solicitor in 2006 for conflicts of interest relating to a tax avoidance scheme. In 2012, he was subject to a civil restraint order for filing repeated claims against the Law Society after his dismissal as a lawyer.

    Paul Baxendale-Walker pleaded guilty to forgery in 2016Denise Truscello/WireImage via Getty Images

    In 2016 he pleaded guilty to forgery after impersonating an investigator contracted by HMRC on a call to the Solicitors Regulatory Authority. Two years later, he was declared bankrupt following a court defeat that found him liable for some £16m on the basis of negligent tax advice.

    “HMRC should have approached Paul Baxendale-Walker with extreme care,” said McCann. “Get some people working on his case who really know what they’re doing, don’t take any risks whatsoever, don’t deviate in any way from what the law says.”

    ‘If HMRC can’t get this guy, it’s hard to see how they can get anyone’

    Dan Neidle, the founder of the independent thinktank Tax Policy Associates and former head of tax at global law firm Clifford Chance, said: “If HMRC can’t get this guy, it’s hard to see how they can get anyone.”

    Paul Baxendale-Walker told TBIJ that his tax advice was made through a partnership that “paid every due penny of tax” and that he had retired a decade ago. He said HMRC’s £14m penalty was based on a “fictional tax liability” and “randomly chosen multiplier”.

    He added: “Every citizen has the right to order their affairs so as to pay the least amount of tax … The evil is accruing a level of taxation which is at a record high since WW2. Not persons who lawfully advise others as to their civil rights and obligations.”

    A spokesperson for HMRC said: “We do not comment on identifiable individuals or businesses.”

    Original article by Ed Siddons republished from TBIJ under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License.

  • Labour’s Otherworldly Manifesto

    Spread the love
    Zionist Keir Starmes is quoted "I support Zionism without qualification." He's asked whether that means that he supports Zionism under all circumstances, whatever Zionists do.
    Zionist Keir Starmes is quoted “I support Zionism without qualification.” He’s asked whether that means that he supports Zionism under all circumstances, whatever Zionists do.

    https://www.rosalux.de/en/news/id/52233/labours-otherworldly-manifesto

    Keir Starmer’s party is set to win by a landslide, but its ambitions are simultaneously unrealistic and uninspiring

    AUTHOR: Keir Milburn

    “Stability is Change!” This seemingly paradoxical, almost Orwellian statement is the principal slogan of the Labour Party’s current parliamentary election campaign. Labour leader Keir Starmer used the slogan at the party’s manifesto launch, and it provides a key prism for understanding the manifesto and its weaknesses.

    There is little doubt that the UK electorate is in the mood for change. The widespread, off-stated consensus in the country is that nothing works. The National Health Service is so chronically underfunded that doctor’s appointments are difficult to get and long waiting lists proliferate. The trains are shockingly expensive but utterly unreliable.

    The list could go on and on, but the image most frequently used to sum up the situation comes from the failure of the privatized water services. A lack of investment in infrastructure accompanied by the looting of those companies for huge shareholder dividend payouts has led to the near constant release of untreated sewage into the UK’s river system. It flows from there onto our beaches. The British are quite literally swimming in shit!

    These problems are identified quite clearly in the Labour Party manifesto, but the diagnosis of their causes and therefore their solutions proves much less convincing. Labour may have a plan to win in July, but how it will govern in the interests of its voters is anybody’s guess.

    …

    The totality of Labour’s spending pledges amounts to just 0.2 percent of GDP, smaller even than the Conservative pledges of 0.8 percent and dwarfed by the previous two Labour manifestos, which promised 2.1 percent and 3.2 percent respectively. Even the pro-market Institute for Fiscal Studies called Labour’s plans “tiny, going on trivial”.

    These policies do not point to stability, not least because they do not address the 18 billion pounds of government spending cuts that the Conservatives have already baked into the government budget going forward. The effects of implementing such cuts on government services — which have already suffered so badly under 14 years of severe austerity — makes it hard to imagine that Labour will stick to this commitment. It seems likely that money will be found to prevent the worst of these cuts through technical changes in accounting between the government and the notionally independent Bank of England.

    Beyond this paddling, however, the need for investment in the UK is huge. Both public and private investment in the country has collapsed since 2008. It has the lowest business investment in the G7 and ranks just twenty-eighth out of the 31 OECD countries. In the face of this, Labour, hamstrung by self-imposed fiscal rules on bringing down government debt and pledges not to raise the main forms of taxation, are promising so little investment that their plans seem unbelievable.

    …

    Until last February, Labour was promising to immediately strengthen workers’ rights through a New Deal for Workers, and to spend 28 billion pounds per year to decarbonize the economy through its Green Prosperity Plan. The Labour Party’s current openness to corporate funding and lobbying, including the imposition of over 30 parliamentary candidates with corporate lobbying backgrounds, has led to a dramatic watering down of these pledges. The Green Prosperity Plan has been reduced to just 3.5 billion pounds, but the form that spending will take reveals another logic or worldview which may come to the fore as crises mount.

    The word “securonomics”, an ugly portmanteau favoured by shadow chancellor Rachel Reeves, makes an appearance in the manifesto, introducing the idea that public investment should support and de-risk private investment in strategically key sectors. The chief vehicle for this will be a National Wealth Fund “capitalised with £7.3 billion over the course of the next parliament”. What precisely this will look like has yet to be determined, but The National Wealth Fund “will have a target of attracting three pounds of private investment for every one pound of public investment”. This is an explicit return to and acceleration of the kind of public-private partnerships that lost legitimacy in the UK during the fallout from the disastrous Public Finance Initiative under New Labour.

    …

    Recommended article at https://www.rosalux.de/en/news/id/52233/labours-otherworldly-manifesto

  • UN to Warn Half a Million Gazans Facing ‘Catastrophic’ Food Insecurity

    Spread the love

    Original article by BRETT WILKINS republished from Common Dreams under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0).

    Children receive malnourishment treatment at Al-Aqsa Martyrs Hospital in Deir al-Balah in the central Gaza Strip on May 30, 2024, amid Israel’s ongoing assault on the besieged enclave. (Photo: Bashar Taleb/AFP via Getty Images)

    “The international community must apply relentless pressure to achieve a cease-fire and ensure sustained humanitarian access now,” said one advocate.

    More than 1 in 5 people in the Gaza Strip are “facing catastrophic levels of food insecurity” amid Israel’s relentless assault and siege against the Palestinian territory, according to a draft report set to be published Tuesday by the United Nations’ hunger monitoring system.

    The latest Integrated Food Security Phase Classification (IPC) Acute Food Insecurity Special Snapshot—which was previewed by various news agencies—says that more than 495,000 Gazans—who already face “an extreme lack of food, starvation, and exhaustion”—are expected to suffer the highest level of starvation over the coming months.

    The draft report states that while a sharp increase in food aid in northern Gaza in March and April can be credited with “likely averting a famine,” the situation is “deteriorating again following renewed hostilities.”

    “A high risk of famine persists across the whole of the Gaza Strip as long as conflict continues and humanitarian access is restricted,” IPC noted.

    The IPC draft report also says more than half of all Gaza households had to sell or swap clothing in order to obtain food, and that the majority of Gazan families often “do not have any food to eat in the house, and over 20% go entire days and nights without eating.”

    “The population cannot endure these hardships any longer.”

    Kate Phillips-Barrasso, vice president of global policy and advocacy at Mercy Corps, an Oregon-based humanitarian NGO, told The Guardian that “people are enduring subhuman conditions resorting to desperate measures like boiling weeds, eating animal feed, and exchanging clothes for money to stave off hunger and keep their children alive.”

    “The humanitarian situation is deteriorating rapidly, and the specter of famine continues to hang over Gaza,” she added. “The international community must apply relentless pressure to achieve a cease-fire and ensure sustained humanitarian access now. The population cannot endure these hardships any longer.”

    Although the IPC stopped short of the rare step of declaring a famine in Gaza, it warned that “the recent trajectory is negative and highly unstable.”

    “Should this continue, the improvements seen in April could be rapidly reversed,” the agency added.

    The IPC’s famine review panel previously said there is not enough data to make a determination on whether there is a famine in Gaza since research was being blocked by “conflict and humanitarian access constraints.”

    The Geneva-based group Euro-Mediterranean Human Rights Monitor said Monday that “the Famine Review Committee’s inability to declare the current food situation in the Gaza Strip to be a famine does not negate the existence of famine in the strip, as pockets of famine are forming and spreading among different age groups, particularly children, and there is a noticeable increase in deaths from hunger, malnutrition, and related diseases.”

    “The committee’s failure to declare the existence of a famine is solely related to its inability to provide certain technical information because of illegal Israeli restrictions and policies that aim to conceal evidence related to the crimes it commits and prevent criminal investigations into them by independent U.N. and international committees, particularly by preventing these committees from entering the strip,” the group added.

    U.N. World Food Program Executive Director Cindy McCain said last month that “full-blown famine” had taken hold in Gaza and was spreading south. According to Gaza officials, at least 40 people—mostly children—have died from malnutrition and dehydration during the 262-day Israeli onslaught. Almost all of the victims are from northern Gaza.

    Israel began bombing, and later invaded, Gaza after Hamas-led attacks left more than 1,100 Israelis and others dead and over 240 others kidnapped on October 7. At least some of the victims were killed by Israeli forces in so-called “friendly fire” incidents, according to Israeli and international media reports.

    Since then, Israeli forces have killed at least 37,626 Palestinians—most of them women and children—in Gaza, while wounding over 86,000 others, according to Palestinian and international agencies. At least 11,000 people, including over 4,000 children, are missing and presumed dead and buried beneath the rubble of hundreds of thousands of bombed-out homes and other buildings.

    Michael Fakhri, the United Nations special rapporteur on the right to food and a law professor at the University of Oregon, said in late February that Israel is committing genocide by intentionally starving Gazans. Israel’s siege—and Israeli attacks on humanitarian aid shipments, workers, and recipients—are being reviewed by the International Court of Justice as part of a South Africa-led genocide case backed by over 30 countries and regional blocs.

    Original article by BRETT WILKINS republished from Common Dreams under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0).

    Over 20,000 Children Missing in Gaza, With ‘Unknown Number’ in Mass Graves: Report

    ‘Visible Signs of Wasting’: Heat, Forced Malnutrition Strangle People of Gaza

    Biden Continues to Cement a Bloody and Immoral Legacy in Gaza

  • Climate Emergency Causes Extreme Wildfires to Double in Frequency: Study

    Spread the love

    Original article by JULIA CONLEY republished from Common Dreams under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0).

    A firefighter walks toward flames as the Highland Fire burns in Aguana, California, on October 31, 2023. 
    (Photo: David Swanson/AFP via Getty Images)

    “Climate change is not something off in the future,” said one scientist. “It’s happening before our very eyes.”

    New findings about the rising frequency of extreme wildfires have “the fingerprints of climate change” all over them, according to an Australian scientist who led a study published on Monday.

    Calum Cunningham, a postdoctoral researcher at the University of Tasmania in Australia, told The Washington Post that he was driven to examine current trends in the frequency of wildfires after climate deniers suggested that because the global area being burned in blazes is declining, the idea of a growing wildfire crisis is being overblown by concerned scientists.

    While the area destroyed by wildfires is indeed on the decline, analyses that include all fires—the majority of which are small and cause relatively little damage—obscured how the most extreme and destructive wildfires are rapidly growing more frequent.

    Cunningham and his team analyzed data from National Aeronautics and Space Administration satellites, collecting four images of wildfires around the world per day over 21 years. They used the images to identify the 0.01% most extreme wildfires—those that release the most smoke and greenhouse gas emissions due to their size and uncontrollable nature.

    Out of 30 million fires across the world over two decades, the researchers identified the 2,913 most extreme fire events and found that the frequency and intensity of such wildfires has more than doubled since 2003.

    “Climate change is making fire weather more extreme and more frequent in a lot of the world.”

    The problem is rapidly getting worse, the team found: The six years with the most extreme wildfires had all occurred since 2017.

    Trends were particularly troubling in particular regions, like temperate conifer forests in the western United States and the Mediterranean, where the number of extreme fires rose by more than 10 times in 20 years.

    In boreal forests in places like northern Europe and Canada, the frequency of the most intense and hard-to-control blazes increased by seven times.

    “It’s absolutely in keeping with what climate change is doing to fire weather around the world,” Cunningham told the Post. “Climate change is making fire weather more extreme and more frequent in a lot of the world.”

    The “fire weather” that’s driven the increase includes hotter and drier conditions, with temperatures staying high even overnight when they ordinarily would have have dropped in previous decades, giving firefighters a chance to make headway in putting out blazes.

    “Rarely did we have 100,000-acre fires 20 years ago,” veteran firefighter Bobbie Scopa told the Post. “But now, it’s not uncommon.”

    The researchers pointed to a “scary” feedback loop created as extreme wildfires create carbon emissions—leading to more planetary heating and even more fires.

    “Climate change is not something off in the future,” Cunningham told the Post. “It’s happening before our very eyes. This is the manifestation of the reshaping of the climate we are doing.”

    The study was published in Nature Ecology & Evolution days after wildfires scorched more than 14,000 acres in Southern California and more than 24,000 acres in New Mexico, where two people were killed. Last year, climate scientists were stunned by an unprecedented wildfire season in relatively damp Eastern Canada, where wildfires were made twice as likely by the climate emergency according to the World Weather Attribution.

    Climate scientist and author Bill McGuire called the findings “terrifying, of course, but just not a surprise,” considering governments in the countries that produce the most fossil fuels are continuing to support and subsidize energy sources that heat the planet.

    “This is certifiably insane,” McGuire said.

    Original article by JULIA CONLEY republished from Common Dreams under Creative Commons (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0).

  • Julian Assange released from prison, WikiLeaks says, after striking deal with US justice department

    Spread the love

    News is breaking that Julian Assange associated with the Wikileaks news publishing site has been released.

    Julian Assange speaks at London's Ecuadorian Embassy
    Julian Assange speaks at London’s Ecuadorian Embassy

    https://www.theguardian.com/media/article/2024/jun/25/julian-assange-plea-deal-with-us-free-to-return-australia

    …

    WikiLeaks said on X that Assange had left Belmarsh prison on Monday morning, after 1,901 days of captivity there. He had spent the time, the organisation said, “in a 2×3 metre cell, isolated 23 hours a day”.

    Assange was set to be reunited with his wife, Stella, who confirmed on X that he was free. She thanked Assange’s supporters, saying “words cannot express our immense gratitude”.

    In the WikiLeaks video, Assange, looking healthy dressed in a shirt and jeans with his white hair cut short, is seen climbing the stairs into a plane.

    An Australian government spokesperson did not confirm or deny the plea deal but said Canberra was “aware” of the legal proceedings, adding: “prime minister [Anthony] Albanese has been clear – Mr Assange’s case has dragged on for too long and there is nothing to be gained by his continued incarceration.”

    Assange’s mother Christine welcomed the developments, saying “I am grateful my son’s ordeal is finally coming to an end.”

    The plea agreement comes months after the US president, Joe Biden, said he was considering a request from Australia to drop the US push to prosecute Assange.

    WikiLeaks in 2010 released hundreds of thousands of classified US military documents on Washington’s wars in Afghanistan and Iraq – the largest security breaches of their kind in US military history – along with swaths of diplomatic cables.

    …

    https://www.theguardian.com/media/article/2024/jun/25/julian-assange-plea-deal-with-us-free-to-return-australia