Chilean court reopens case against soldier accused of Gaza war crimes
This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
A recent judicial ruling in Chile has revived scrutiny of a criminal complaint against an Israeli-Ukrainian soldier accused of committing war crimes in the Gaza Strip, reviving a legal debate over the application of universal jurisdiction in the country.
The Santiago Court of Appeals overturned a prior ruling by the Eighth Guarantee Court, which had refused to examine the complaint against Rom Kovtun. The appellate court ruled that the question of jurisdiction cannot be decided without hearing all parties involved.
A public hearing is scheduled for 12th June, where the complainant, the defence, and the Public Prosecutor’s Office will present arguments on whether Chilean courts have the authority to investigate alleged war crimes, crimes against humanity, and genocide committed abroad.
The complaint was filed in February by the Hind Rajab Foundation through Chilean lawyer Pablo Andrés Araya Zacarías. It seeks Kovtun´s investigation under Chilean Law No. 20.357, which criminalises genocide, crimes against humanity, and war crimes, in line with the Rome Statute of the International Criminal Court.
According to the complaint, Kovtun served as a sniper in the 424th “Shaked” Battalion of the Givati Brigade and operated under the 401st Armored Brigade during military operations in Gaza. He is accused of participating in the siege and destruction of the Al-Shifa Medical Complex in Gaza City between March and April 2024. The operation reportedly caused extensive damage to medical infrastructure and civilian casualties, including patients and hospital staff.
https://www.instagram.com/p/DZGQrJrDwAt
Legal experts and human rights advocates caution that the Court of Appeals’ decision does not confirm the allegations or rule on the merits of the case. Its purpose is limited to determining whether Chilean courts have jurisdiction to examine the complaint. The outcome of the June hearing will decide whether Chile proceeds with a formal criminal investigation or dismisses the case as outside its jurisdiction.
READ: Director of ‘The Voice of Hind Rajab’ declines award at Berlin event
Chilean lawyer and former ambassador Nelson Hadad highlighted the lack of legal consistency in Chile regarding universal jurisdiction. “This issue lacks consistent jurisprudence; that is, in most cases, the Chilean judiciary has rejected the principle of universal jurisdiction and the extraterritorial application of the law,” he said.
Regarding the upcoming hearing, Hadad noted, “In this case, there is a hearing scheduled for 10th June in which… will there be a ruling on this matter? It could perhaps be the first time.”
He emphasised the cautious approach of the judiciary and prosecutorial authorities. “The Public Prosecutor’s Office and the Judiciary as such accept some arguments to be able to prosecute in Chile this Israeli soldier responsible for numerous crimes,” Hadad explained.
At the same time, he highlighted past reluctance from Chilean authorities. “But I believe that the Public Prosecutor’s Office, especially the North Central Prosecutor’s Office where Prosecutor Armendariz is, has been consistently reluctant to accept universal jurisdiction,” he said.
Looking ahead, Hadad stressed the potential impact of a favorable ruling. “We are waiting to see what happens because if it were the opposite and it were accepted, it would set a very important legal precedent for trying numerous cases from Chile with the Chilean justice system, crimes committed abroad, in this case, crimes committed in Gaza and throughout occupied Palestine.”
He concluded with cautious optimism: “So we can talk again on 10th June, once the court has ruled on this point. But at least there is hope.”
BLOG: Latin American anger grows over Israel’s detention of Thiago Ávila
The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.
This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
- US CENTCOM commander visits Middle East, meets regional leaders
- Hamas delegation arrives in Egypt for talks on advancing Gaza ceasefire
- Polish football club rejects Israeli transfer offer, compares business ties with Tel Aviv to Nazi Germany
- No military solution will provide security: Lebanese president tells Israel
- Has Europe learned anything from Moria? New migration pact begins in the ashes of a child
- Russia expects to derive $13.6B from Strait of Hormuz oil spike
- IAEA chief says US-Iran talks close to nuclear framework agreement
- Ireland imposes travel ban on 2 Israeli Cabinet ministers
- Iran says navy fired warning shots toward US destroyers in Sea of Oman
- Azerbaijan rejects CNN report alleging territory used for operations against Iran
- Chilean court reopens case against soldier accused of Gaza war crimes
- Nearly 5,000 Belgian academics and students urge universities to cut Israel ties
- Israel, US launch talks to draft new security cooperation framework
- UAE invites citizens and residents to pledge allegiance to president
- Iran’s supreme leader approves pardon for over 2,000 convicts
- Report: Mossad supplied Kurdish forces with weapons seized from Hamas and Hezbollah
- Israeli media: Drone crashes in western Galilee minutes after Netanyahu leaves
- Israeli strike hits home in Zawaida, Gaza
- If Lebanon has no future, neither does the region
- Tunisia receives 48 US-made Humvees to strengthen border security
- Egypt Rejects Guardian Report on Sudanese Refugees, Says It Ignored Cairo’s Efforts
- Trump and Netanyahu: The odd couple
- Report: Israel expands security cooperation with Somaliland
- Podcast by Jasim Al-Azzawi with John W. Miller: The Naval Armada Waiting Offshore, Now What?
- Rights group says 360 Palestinian children are being held in Israeli prisons
- From nuclear threshold to nuclear deterrence: Is Iran crossing the line?
- Iranian FM: US bases are a source of instability in the region
- Iran was ready to turn any Israeli advance on Beirut’s southern suburbs into “hell”, Rezaei says
- Iran seeks to collect service fees, not tolls for crossing Strait of Hormuz
- Violence and Crime Among the Palestinian Community in Israel: The Shattering of the Indigenous
- Iran sets conditions for accepting Trump plan to end war
- Trump says he does not need deal with Iran to get enriched uranium
- Houthi leader says group coordinates with resistance movements over developments in Lebanon, Palestine
- Most people in 36 countries hold unfavorable views of Israel: Poll
- US secretary of state, Kuwait foreign minister discuss regional security amid ‘reprehensible’ Iranian attacks
- UN says Gaza aid response weakening as funding appeal remains below 15%
- Iranian foreign minister, Hamas leader in Gaza discuss latest Palestinian, regional developments
- UN peacekeeper killed, 2 others wounded in shelling in southern Lebanon
- University of Vienna Student Assembly votes for academic boycott of Israeli universities
- France to convene Israeli, Palestinian civil society leaders in Paris to support 2-state solution
- Saudi crown prince reiterates support for Bahrain following Iranian attacks
- Hezbollah rejects Lebanon-Israel ceasefire agreement
- Ex-Israeli premier warns Netanyahu could try to ‘steal’ next elections
- Megawatt diplomacy: Water as the missing link in the new architecture of Middle East energy security
- Kushner floats cash-for-normalisation with Israel to expand ‘Abraham Accords’
- Repetitive folly: Israel’s futile war in Lebanon deepens
- The US creates convenient loopholes for Israel
- Ghannouchi’s defence condemns life sentence in ‘secret apparatus’ case
- Islamic Jihad accuses Israel of continued violations of Gaza ceasefire
- Gaza: Palestinians bid farewell to nine killed in dawn airstrike
