This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
A former head of Israeli military intelligence has said that since 7 October 2023, Israel has been run by an unwritten security doctrine that writes off the US as a declining power, rejects peace as a strategic goal and makes war a permanent feature of national life.
Major General (res.) Tamir Hayman, who now heads Tel Aviv’s Institute for National Security Studies (INSS), sets out the doctrine in a paper the think tank published this week.
Hayman says the new concept has never been written down or presented to the public. Even so, it now “inform[s] decision-making and dictate[s] Israel’s approach to security”. He argues the shift goes beyond military planning and points to “a change in Israel’s national identity”.
The most striking principle is the doctrine’s view of Washington. Hayman says it treats the US as a “declining power” and holds that “excessive adherence to restrictions imposed on Israel by a US administration is dangerous”.
Under this thinking, the US, “given its ongoing social and political shifts, will soon abandon Israel in any event”. Dependence on Washington is also seen as exposing Israel “to the influence of a progressive American value system that is incompatible with Israel’s Jewish character”. Cutting ties with the US is therefore “not only inevitable, but essential to Israel’s independence and the resilience of its Jewish national identity”.
Hayman rejects that view. He points out that Israel is a small country with few natural resources and depends heavily on trade with the rest of the world. For that reason, he says, the country’s security chiefs have always believed it needs a major power on its side, because Israel “cannot sustain an autarkic defence economy isolated from the world”. In other words, Israel is incapable of producing everything it needs for its own defence.
Hayman questions whether a relationship with Washington based only on mutual interest would be enough to protect Israel. He also asks whether cutting Israeli science and arms industries off from international partnerships, such as the EU’s Horizon research programme, would leave Israel facing “technological stagnation and diplomatic isolation”.
Throughout the Gaza genocide, Israel has relied on American weapons and on US diplomatic protection at the UN.
READ: Axios: Netanyahu discussed joint strike on Iran with Trump before Israeli election
Hayman identifies four other major principles behind the new doctrine. Taken together, they describe a state that puts ethnic identity before democracy, sees peace as a trap and treats war as normal.
The first is that Israel’s Jewish identity comes before its democracy. Under the doctrine, the state must stay Jewish “even at the cost of eroding its democratic values”. Hayman asks whether Israel can still call itself “Jewish and democratic” if it pursues a policy of curbing the civil rights of its Palestinian citizens, who make up about a fifth of the population.
The second principle rejects peace altogether. The doctrine holds that “a meaningful peace agreement is unattainable in the Middle East” and assumes that “any arrangement with Arab actors is temporary and deceptive”.
The doctrine treats peace deals as “merely technical and temporary arrangements”. Peace has no value of its own and is only “a means of achieving other policy objectives”. Peace itself is dismissed as “a naive concept” belonging to the left-wing “peace camp”, and set against “security”, which belongs to the right.
The third is contempt for Israel’s Arab neighbours as states. The doctrine views most of them as “not genuine nation-states, but collections of tribes and ethnic groups lacking a shared history”. It therefore sees their collapse as “a natural process” that Israel can manage and “should even encourage”.
The fourth is that war is Israel’s normal condition, not an exception. Preventive war is preferred, and the “constant presence” of war is considered “an asset to national security”. The paper quotes the slogan “Silence is filth” to sum up the view that seeking peace is a sign of weakness.
The doctrine goes further on territory. It calls for “forward defence” zones and civilian settlements in the occupied West Bank and in security zones inside Syria, Lebanon and the Gaza Strip. It rules out a Palestinian state and dismisses the Palestinian national movement as “an inauthentic Western narrative”.
Hayman says the doctrine draws its power from never being stated openly. It works “as an unwritten concept revealed through practice, rather than as a government’s declared policy”. He calls for a public debate on whether it is “a necessary adaptation” to Israel’s security situation or “an expression of a fundamental, unchecked shift in the state’s identity”.
READ: Israel raises alert levels amid fears of renewed war with Iran
This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
- Egypt has ‘no hidden agendas,’ ambitions against anyone: President
- Saudi football league postpones 3 matches after Houthi attacks
- Indonesia slams Israel for discriminating against one of its pilots
- 4 Palestinians killed, several others injured in Israeli airstrikes in Gaza despite ceasefire
- Lebanese president, top Iranian diplomat stress diplomatic solutions to regional conflicts
- Yemeni army claims 1,250 Houthis ‘neutralized’ in ‘Dawn of Yemen’ operation
- Palestine says Colombia’s opening of embassy in West Jerusalem violates international law
- Pakistan reiterates ‘unwavering’ commitment to Saudi Arabia’s protection under Makkah defense pact
- Iran says container ship sank after striking naval mine in Strait of Hormuz
- Israel’s elections: Netanyahu wants more than victory; he wants to stop others from governing
- Israeli army opens fire on water tanker, drives away shepherds in southwestern Syria
- 3 seriously injured in explosion at Intel factory in southern Israel
- 5,500-year-old olive tree continues to thrive in Bethlehem despite drought, conflict
- French viewers shocked by Israeli soldiers’ accounts of Gaza in ‘NAZA’ documentary
- Colombia opens embassy in West Jerusalem despite city’s disputed international status
- Iraqi premier arrives in Saudi Arabia on 1st official visit
- Yemen’s Houthi rebels threaten further attacks on Saudi airports, oil facilities
- Israeli occupiers burn prayer room, car, scrawl racist slogans in occupied Jerusalem
- Israeli settlers pick olives from Palestinian-owned trees in West Bank
- Bishop calls for international action after settlers attack West Bank centre for disabled children
- Returning to Gaza after two years
- Israel now treats US as ‘declining power’ and war as permanent condition, says former intelligence chief
- Axios: Netanyahu discussed joint strike on Iran with Trump before Israeli election
- Netanyahu acknowledges former Egyptian intelligence chief visited Israel before 7 October attack
- Spain’s king reasserts sovereignty over Ceuta, Melilla as Morocco remains silent
- Israel raises alert levels amid fears of renewed war with Iran
- Netanyahu labels Tulkarm camp residents ‘terrorists,’ vows to prevent their return
- Palestinian prisoners’ office says detained doctor beaten in presence of Ben Gvir
- Israel seeks security personnel at UAE airports as condition for resuming Flydubai flights
- Australia, Canada, France and UK urge Abbas to reconsider postponement of Palestinian elections
- IMF forecasts 3.3% contraction of Saudi economy amid regional conflict and Houthi attacks
- Hamas condemns Israeli raids on Ramallah rights groups and arrests in Nablus
- America’s broken promises, Iran’s resolve, and the dangerous game over the Strait of Hormuz
- Saudi-led coalition intercepts 2 Houthi ballistic missiles targeting eastern Saudi Arabia
- Israeli forces raid Ramallah, shut down offices of several organizations
- Iran’s IRGC Navy threatens to sink US warships approaching Strait of Hormuz
- UN experts urge food agency to uphold human rights amid concerns about Gaza-related work
- If You Cannot Say Genocide: Essays on Conscience and Witness
- 2 Palestinians killed, others injured in Israeli attacks in Gaza despite ceasefire
- Syria accuses Israel of arming, funding militias in Suwayda to sow ‘chaos’
- Global day of action for Palestine: Millions mobilise across 60 countries in synchronised worldwide solidarity
- Trump says Houthis acting ‘very badly’ amid intensifying attacks
- One year since the ceasefire, the UN commemorates its failures
- Americans urged to reconsider travel to Saudi Arabia over Iranian, Houthi attack threats
- Saudi-led coalition launches airstrikes on Houthi positions in Yemen’s Sanaa
- IsDB chief in Jakarta: A US$2.56 billion plan with a missing climate pillar
- ‘Peace Requires Justice’: Why Washington and Tel Aviv Want Neither | Palestine This Week
- Israel elections: Palestinian state caught between Netanyahu’s incitement, Eisenkot’s rejection
- Iranian attacks target 6 ships near Strait of Hormuz in 1 day, highest since war with US began
- On the universality of Gazan resistance: A century-long struggle for human rights
