The EU does not need to clarify its support for Israeli colonialism
This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Israeli colonialism entrenched an apartheid system. The reality has been documented multiple times and acknowledged even within Israel, most prominently by the non-governmental organisation B’Tselem in 2021. Recently, the EU High Representative Kaja Kallas was reported to have used the term apartheid during a visit to Mexico. Kallas has made several contradictory statements since the start of the genocide which reflect both the EU’s lack of political cohesion over sanctioning Israel, as well as the underlying concern to safeguard Israel’s impunity.
However, Kallas’s remark comparing Israel to South African apartheid, has been blown out of proportion and out of all realms of credibility by Israel’s Foreign Minister Gideon Sa’ar, who expressed displeasure at Kallas’s comment and blatantly called Israel “the only democracy in the Middle East”. Not even the world’s former colonial powers truly believe that statement, despite how times it is publicly uttered and endorsed. Former colonial powers recognise colonialism when they see it.
Kallas’s response to Sa’ar stating he will sever all contact was replete with the usual contradictions, except for the assertion that “The EU is always committed to a constructive relationship with Israel.” Other than that, prioritising the two-state paradigm as the only solution, while noting that the implementation is becoming impossible due to illegal settlement construction, represents the usual EU position, as reflected in Kallas’s post on X.
READ: Gaza shifts US politics as pro-Israel lobby suffers setback in New York primaries
The two-state is not a solution, and it is not just settlement expansion that makes the two-state obsolete. It is colonialism, which the entire world refuses to address, in order to maintain Israel’s presence in Palestine.
The diplomatic spat is nothing but a useless spectacle. Israel revels in finding inconsequential distractions, many of them diplomatic, that briefly shift attention away from more pressing issues, such as the fact that Palestinians in Gaza remain forcibly displaced despite all the talk of reconstruction.
Kallas, meanwhile, responded with the usual statements that reassure Israel of the EU’s commitment to safeguarding colonialism, despite the visible purported disagreements. Sa’ar, for example, accused Kallas of “acting obsessively and with blatant unfairness towards the State of Israel”, yet the only unfairness has been solely directed against the Palestinian people.
Colonialism is abnormal, and the EU supports it. Why, for example, did Kallas seek to placate Sa’ar instead of taking a firmer stance against Israel’s apartheid system? An utterance by a high ranking official could have been followed by at least a stronger assertion, not to mention that the EU could take political, diplomatic and economic measures that directly target Israel. Instead, the rhetoric is shifted to the two-state paradigm, which is obsolete and which Israel opposes. So much for Kallas being described as anti-Israel, when the response to Sa’ar’s complaint was to find common ground for further Israeli colonial expansion.
Israel implemented apartheid, and it also committed genocide. In light of Kallas’s unofficial comment, the EU’s Ambassador to Israel Michael Mann told the Jerusalem Post, “It is not the official policy of the European Union that Israel is an apartheid state. I want to make that absolutely clear.”
It is absolutely clear. So much that there is no need for clarification, not even when a diplomatic dispute arises.
BLOG: Symbolism for Palestinians is impunity for Israeli colonialism
The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.
This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
- Israeli prime minister faces calls to resign during military ceremony: Report
- US, Gulf states call for reopening Hormuz, reject ‘any tolls, fees, or attempts to assert control’ over waterway
- Hundreds of Palestinians protest Israeli policies of home demolitions in Negev
- 2 killed, 7 injured in RSF drone strike on fuel station in southern Sudan: Medics
- Iran’s parliament speaker rejects US claim unfrozen assets will fund American farm goods
- The EU does not need to clarify its support for Israeli colonialism
- Life Support: doctors in Gaza bear witness to genocide
- Israel’s flag carrier suspends Moscow flights over security concerns: Reports
- Israel’s security chiefs revisit Gaza expulsion plan despite global rejection
- Iraqi Oil Ministry denies reports of potential OPEC exit, urges output quota reassessment
- Power, water, and governance: The roots of Iran’s summer blackouts
- Former Israeli leaders threaten court action over state-backed ‘Jewish terrorism’ in West Bank
- Israeli forces kill Palestinian man inside home in occupied West Bank raid
- Gaza shifts US politics as pro-Israel lobby suffers setback in New York primaries
- Israel prepares to resume fighting on Yemen front, updates plans against Houthis
- 215 civilians die in RSF-run prison in South Darfur: Sudanese medics
- Iranian, Saudi foreign ministers discuss US negotiations, regional developments
- Ultra-orthodox Jews protests disrupt traffic across Israel amid opposition to military conscription
- Oil, elites, and empty promises: Inside the US-backed coup against the UN in Libya
- Report: Israeli officials lobby Washington over proposed Turkey-Saudi trade corridor
- Shin Bet chief orders removal of memorial for 7 October victims to avoid ‘constant reminder of defeat’
- Washington talks stall as Israel refuses to leave southern Lebanon
- Trump says Turkey was poised to join war alongside Iran
- Awakening human consciousness to the reality of the horrific genocide in Gaza
- ‘Shocking’ photo of freed Palestinian journalist shows ‘tragic’ conditions in Israeli prisons: Rights group
- Israel declares 115 acres as ‘state land’ to expand illegal West Bank settlement
- Israel forces destroy cemetery containing remains of Canadian soldiers in Gaza
- The illusions of Western virtue: Ursula von der Leyen and Europe’s moral bankruptcy
- Israeli Cabinet minister brags about demolishing 5,700 Palestinians homes in 1 year, vows to demolish more
- Thank you, Israel, for overplaying the empire’s hand
- Israeli media highlight concerns over Egypt’s growing military capabilities
- Israeli minister says army won’t leave occupied territory in Lebanon ‘even if US demands’ it
- Critical minerals: The next energy battle in West Asia
- “The Jewish KKK” and the Catastrophe Jewish Critics Warned Was Coming | Palestine This Week
- Netanyahu’s corruption case testimony concludes after 98 hearings
- Trump warns Iran negotiations would end if tolls imposed on ships
- Israeli minister warns US will soon find itself ‘on collision course’ with Tel Aviv over Iran deal
- From “never again” to the “gates of hell” in Gaza and Lebanon
- Luhut’s BlackRock outreach legitimises genocide in Gaza
- Tales of the Palestinian wheat sheaves: When a harvest turns to ash
- Gaza is not Netanyahu’s exit; it may be his political end
- Pakistan PM: US-Iran memorandum excludes ballistic missile issue
- Iran air defence forces on full alert, senior commander says
- Gaza officials warn of ‘silent famine’ as aid deliveries fall far below planned levels
- Moroccan Army officers arrive in Israel to join Gaza stabilisation force
- Human Rights Watch urges Jordan to reinstate death penalty moratorium after six executions
- Iran says Israeli strikes on Lebanon delayed next round of US talks
- Israeli fears grow over soldier capture attempt in southern Lebanon
- Israeli soldiers’ parents demand end to Lebanon fighting and return of troops
- Netanyahu to hold meeting on Israeli concerns over possible Syrian role in Lebanon
PSC Cymru co-chairwoman Bethan Sayed [… and what?]
