This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
“This is not incidental violence. It is the architecture of settler-colonialism, built on a foundation of dehumanisation and maintained by a policy of cruelty and collective terror.” The concluding sentence to the summary of UN Special Rapporteur Francesca Albanese’s report to the UN Human Rights Council on torture and genocide succinctly sums up how Israel has been using torture as part of its gradual annihilation of the Palestinian people. Since October 2023, torture has become a weapon in Israel’s genocide.
Albanese notes that while torture is a crime under international law, the Genocide Convention describes torture as an underlying act of genocide “when inflicted with the intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a protected group “as such”. Genocide, Albanese explains from the legal framework of the Genocide Convention, “many be committed through sustained practices that break bodies, minds and collective resilience.”
READ: Israeli army demolishes Palestinian park, car showroom in occupied West Bank
The historical realities of torture since the British Mandate contextualises the current torture practices Israel inflicts on Palestinians today. British torture practices were incorporated by Israel after 1948. In 1987, the Landau Commission effectively ruled in favour of torture “on a person suspected of involvement in terrorist activities.” With impunity assigned a foundation, what happens when a settler-colonial entity which treats Palestinians as legitimate targets for annihilation, blatantly considers all Palestinians as terrorists?
Torture becomes normalised, and because the international community has already subscribed to Israel’s security narrative, there is no opposition to a practice that, as Albanese illustrated, also constitutes an underlying act of genocide.
It is not Israel’s torture of Palestinian detainees since October 2023 that catches attention when reading the report, but the analysis of how Israel uses genocide as a means of torture. Albanese’s report illustrates how mass displacement, the destruction of Gaza’s infrastructure and cultural sites, the erasure of collective memory through such destruction, the destruction of the healthcare system, starvation, permanent disabilities, as well as Israeli weaponry used against Palestinians in Gaza all constitute forms of torture. The same applies to the occupied West Bank, where sophisticated surveillance and military incursions, the destruction of refugee camps and agricultural land, all constitute forms of torture and genocidal violence.
READ: Gaza death toll from Israeli war nears 72,300, Health Ministry says
Having prioritised Israel’s security narrative over rights, both the Knesset and Israel’s judiciary have normalised torture. Albanese writes, “Torture has thus become a collective enterprise,” showing how the entire fabric of Israeli society renders itself a participant in torture practices through the settler-colonial narrative. “by targeting the totality of the people, across the totality of the occupied land, through a totality of conduct, genocide has become the ultimate form of torture: continuous, generational and collective.”
Justice, Albanese stated, should “confront torture not as an isolated crime, but as a foundational pillar of the genocidal project aimed at the complete erasure – physical and psychological destruction, displacement and replacement – of the Palestinian people.” Torture as state policy has ensured that no aspect of Palestinian life is immune. The report illustrates what statistical data omits – the price Palestinians are paying in their daily lives for the international community’s complicity with colonialism and genocide.
BLOG: The UN leaves UNRWA isolated, and Palestinians prone to genocide
The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.
This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
- Torture, genocide and erasure
- French students announce legal action over universities’ ties with Israel
- Hezbollah launches 600 projectiles in 24 hours: Israeli media
- Pentagon getting ready for huge ‘final blow’ in Iran war: Report
- Iranian attacks, Hormuz closure ‘crossed all red lines’: Gulf bloc
- Iran Is Not Denying Negotiations. It Is Designing Them
- Volkswagen considers move into Iron Dome production at German site
- Israeli defense minister claims to have killed Iran’s IRGC Navy commander
- Gaza death toll from Israeli war nears 72,300, Health Ministry says
- Trump says NATO has done ‘absolutely nothing’ on Iran
- Iranian parliament considers charging ships passing through Strait of Hormuz
- Rafah crossing partially reopens for Gaza patients
- Israel fears potential US ceasefire with Iran could undermine war goals
- Palestinian Foreign Ministry welcomes UN report on settlement expansion
- Iranian forces say they targeted US-linked sites in Kuwait, Saudi Arabia, and Bahrain
- Former Israeli Supreme Court judge doubts Netanyahu will receive pardon
- Hezbollah says 2 ambushes destroyed 10 Israeli Merkava tanks
- Uganda military chief says country would join war if Israel faces defeat
- When presidents lie, diplomacy dies: The global cost of post-truth under Trump