Category: Green Party

  • Government makes £5bn a year from immigration fees while applicants are forced into debt

    Spread the love

    Article republished from TBIJ under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. Charts are visible in the original article.

    Home Office’s visa and citizenship fees are up to 10 times the processing cost – and rising every year

    In brief

    • The government’s vast profits from the UK visa system run counter to claim that migrants are a financial burden on the state
    • Fees charged for visas, citizenship and health surcharge far outstrip the actual cost to the Home Office
    • Families trying to settle and stay in the UK are giving up basic essentials to cover tens of thousands in costs

    When Bethany Sparrow fell in love, she didn’t expect that moving in with her partner would put her on the breadline.

    She and Moheb met on holiday in Tunisia and they got married a year and a half later. But to live together in the UK, they discovered, they would have to pay the British government £5,000.

    Already working full-time as a teaching assistant for children with autism, Bethany took a second job at JD Sports on weekends and school holidays. That still wasn’t enough, so she started cutting back on essentials – “sacrificing everyday normal things, sacrificing food”.

    “[The government’s] not thinking about what it’s doing to families, how emotionally exhausting it is, how much we’re having to save,” she said. “I lost so much weight … [It was] the worst experience I’ve ever dealt with in my whole life. You can’t even put into words how mentally draining it is.”

    After almost a year, though, they saved enough for Moheb’s visa and, in March, he moved to the UK. But even with both of them working and saving everything they can, they are unsure if they will be able to afford his visa renewal when it is due in 2028.

    Bethany Sparrow at home with her husband Moheb Phil Hitchman

    Reunite Families UK, a nonprofit organisation supporting families affected by visa rules, estimates that visa and citizenship applications could end up costing Bethany and her husband more than £13,000.

    The couple are not alone. Hundreds of thousands of people are forced to pay these rising fees every year – and many have amassed eye-watering debts to cover the costs. The majority are people who have already been in the UK for years and are looking to renew their visas or settle.

    And, contrary to the common claim that migrants are a financial burden on the country, the British state makes billions of pounds in profit from these fees – some of which are more than 10 times the actual administrative cost.

    According to our analysis, the government raked in almost £5bn last year in profit from various visa, citizenship and immigration charges. That’s more than it gets in corporation tax from all of the energy, gas, water, sewage and hospitality industries combined.

    https://flo.uri.sh/visualisation/30222882/embed?auto=1

    Made with Flourish • Create a chart

    “I think the government knows how desperate people are to stay in this country, so they’re taking advantage,” said Rumbidzai Bvunzawabaya, a solicitor and CEO of Tulia, a charity that supports migrant workers. “And what makes it worse is that then they always scapegoat migrants and say they’re just coming in to freeload.”

    Matteo Besana, head of policy and advocacy at Reunite Families UK, said it was “a national scandal that the Home Office has been allowed to profiteer for as long as it has”.

    “The current visa system is a form of double taxation that deliberately keeps people and children in poverty. No government should be able to justify this.”

    ‘Easy money’

    The UK has the most expensive immigration fees in Europe. In part, this is because it makes a profit on most applications. But this wasn’t always the case.

    Around 20 years ago, people only had to pay what it cost the government to process the visa. For Bethany and her husband that would have meant a one-off charge of £260. Other visas were even cheaper.

    This changed in 2005 under Tony Blair’s government. Since then visa costs have spiralled far above the rate of inflation.

    To give one example, the cost of a settlement application, also known as indefinite leave to remain (ILR), has increased by more than 20 times in the space of two decades, from £155 to £3,226. Similar increases have taken place with work visas, citizenship applications for UK-born children of immigrants, and for student visas, among others.

    https://flo.uri.sh/visualisation/30248585/embed?auto=1

    Made with Flourish • Create a chart

    Then, in 2015, the Conservative and Liberal Democrat coalition government added another fee many migrants had to pay on top of their visas: the immigration health surcharge. The charge, which helps fund the health system, can cost someone as much as £1,035 per year.

    The Oxford Immigration Observatory calls it a form of “double taxation”. Migrants, who already pay more in tax than they take out of the system, are then charged again via the surcharge.

    The research centre estimates that, through the different charges and renewals, someone on the skilled worker visa will pay upwards of £24,000 before they can become a British citizen. A family with one child could pay over £40,000.

    Layla Hussain, advocacy officer at the charity Refugee & Migrant Justice said the government is making “obscene profits” from migrants who then face barriers to building their lives in the UK.

    Recommended Articles

    She described young people being prevented from going to university because of their immigration status, parents having to choose between feeding their children and paying fees, and families taking on debts that take decades to repay.

    A Home Office spokesperson denied that the government profited from these fees, saying the money is put towards the wider migration and borders system. This includes immigration enforcement, border force and detention centres.

    The spokesperson said: “It is right that those who benefit from the migration and borders system contribute towards its costs, reducing the burden on taxpayers.” They added that the health surcharge ensures migrants make a “fair contribution” to the NHS.

    But the scale of the fees have historically been opposed by politicians who now hold senior positions in government.

    In 2018, Yvette Cooper, now the health and social care secretary, said the scale of citizenship fees “has become a real and growing problem”.

    Stephen Doughty, a minister in the Commonwealth and Development Office previously called for a review into the fees being charged saying “it is never acceptable … to make a profit on these crucial activities”.

    David Lammy, who until recently was deputy prime minister, said while in opposition that people were being “exploited by excessive fees”.

    As part of this story we asked them if they stood by these statements. None of them replied.

    “Now, when they have the chance to make things better, they have not only gone quiet but are set to massively increase charges for migrants through the Immigration and Asylum Bill,” said Green Party MP Sian Berry.

    “The government is treating people who have built their lives here as a source of easy money, regardless of the hardship it causes.”

    The bill Berry refers to is proposing to extend the period people have to spend in the UK before they can settle to as long as 30 years. This will mean people will face more visa renewals – and with them, more fees.

    The government is treating people who have built their lives here as a source of easy money

    Sian Berry, Green Party MP

    When proposing immigration changes earlier this year, the home secretary Shabana Mahmood justified them by suggesting immigrants are a burden on the taxpayer.

    Such claims have largely been debunked, with even the Office For Budget Responsibility, the government’s independent forecaster, estimating that reducing net migration by 100,000 per year would leave the public purse £7bn worse off a five-year period.

    ‘A disaster’

    People on the lowest incomes can apply for a fee waiver on some visa applications, but as 78-year-old Pat Dore discovered, the decisions are not always fair.

    Pat’s son, a former software developer, has been unable to work since developing ME and couldn’t afford to pay for his wife and daughter’s visas. Initially, Pat paid the combined £7,000 visa and surcharge fees, amassing credit card debt in the process. She had already been failed once by the state, as a victim of the Post Office scandal, and she used her compensation from that ordeal to cover the costs.

    But when it came time to renew the visas two and a half years later, the family had no savings left. Pat’s son applied for a fee waiver – and it was refused.

    As part of the application, he had provided bank statements from his Smile account. In its rejection, the Home Office said that records showed he had a bank account with the Co-op, which he had not disclosed. But Smile is a brand name for the Co-op; the account they were asking for was the one he had told them about.

    Pat has now increased her credit card limit to cover this second set of visa and solicitor fees.

    A government review from last year found several cases of Home Office officials making mistakes on fee waiver applications, including refusing an application from a homeless 18-year-old because she could not provide copies of bank statements or a tenancy agreement.

    “I had high hopes for Labour,” Pat said. “[But] if you’ve got disabled people in your family and immigrants, it’s a disaster because they’re the two people they’ve gone for.”

    ‘To somebody else I don’t belong’

    John Mataruse, 44, and his family were among the lucky ones. Originally a relationship manager at a bank in Zimbabwe, he came to the UK in 2021 after his wife was offered a job as a nurse in the NHS. As a health worker, the family was exempt from paying the health surcharge and their initial visas were cheaper than those of other skilled workers.

    When it came to applying for settlement, they had to pay the same as everyone else. The full bill for all four family members, including language tests and biometrics, came to more than £15,000. They couldn’t afford this sum so took out a personal loan which will take them years to pay off.

    If the Home Office had charged them what it costs to process the applications, they would have paid £1,240.

    ILR applications are among the most profitable for the Home Office: only £310 of the £3,226 charge covers the actual administrative cost of processing the application.

    https://flo.uri.sh/visualisation/30212676/embed?auto=1

    Made with Flourish • Create a chart

    John’s family also paid an extra £2,000 to fast-track the applications and avoid spending up to six months in a state of limbo waiting for the government to make a decision.

    He could have waited, but he says he was worried the government could change the rules and leave his family in an uncertain situation for even longer, racking up visa charges for years. It’s a choice many people are facing with the looming immigration bill.

    Fatima*, who arrived in the UK from Pakistan when she was five, told us that her family put the cost of her ILR application on a credit card they couldn’t afford.

    She estimates that by the time they are able to pay it all back, they would have paid twice as much as the original fee in interest payments.

    Fatima says she comes from a country looted by the British Empire. Her family members fought for Britain in two world wars. “I feel this should be free… if anything the Home Office should compensate us.”

    For both Fatima and John, permanent residency has brought some peace of mind, albeit at a steep cost. But John says there is another side to it.

    Referring to the recent Belfast riots that targeted migrant communities, he says: “I paid all that, but in a moment a demonstration can lead me to running away from my home.

    “Yes, I’m settled. But then at the same time, to somebody else, I still don’t belong … There are many good people around, but also when you look at the news you realise that a few bad people can make life hell for you.”

    Because of this, on top of the debt repayments, John is also trying to save money in case he needs to return to Zimbabwe.

    “At least there no one can tell me to go back to where I came from,” he said.

    * Name has been changed

    Reporter: Emiliano Mellino
    Bureau Local editor: Gareth Davies
    Deputy editor: Katie Mark
    Editor: Franz Wild
    Production editor: Alex Hess
    Fact checker: Josephine Moulds

    The Bureau has a number of funders, a full list of which can be found here. None of our funders have any influence over editorial decisions or output.

    Article republished from TBIJ under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License. Charts are visible in the original article.

  • Britain’s democracy at risk, campaigners warn after billionaires gift Reform UK £72m

    Spread the love

    https://morningstaronline.co.uk/article/britains-democracy-risk-campaigners-warn-after-billionaires-gift-reform-uk-ps72m

     Reform UK leader Nigel Farage

    TRANSPARENCY campaigners warned Britain’s democracy is at growing risk of being bought by the highest bidder after two billionaires pledged £72 million to Reform UK.

    Crypto-billionaires Ben Delo and Christopher Harborne each decided to give £36m

    …

    Green Party deputy leader Rachel Millward branded Reform “a vessel for the super wealthy.”

    She added: “They will always act in the interests of the super wealthy.

    “Labour could have stopped this years ago by capping donations. Burnham promised to do it then backtracked. Will he now admit this was a mistake?

    “Burnham and Labour have been quiet on a donations cap for the last 24 hours. The public needs to know where he stands.”

    https://morningstaronline.co.uk/article/britains-democracy-risk-campaigners-warn-after-billionaires-gift-reform-uk-ps72m

    Nigel Farage admits to being a whore willing to do anything for someone with a big fat wallet and asks whether drinking pints and smoking fags is not enough for the stupid plebs.
    Nigel Farage admits to being a whore willing to do anything for someone with a big fat wallet and asks whether drinking pints and smoking fags is not enough for the stupid plebs.
    Nigel Farage says he's too stupid to answer questions about the hit to the UK economy of his plans to suck up to the uber-rich.
    Nigel Farage says he’s too stupid to answer questions about the hit to the UK economy of his plans to suck up to the uber-rich.
    Nigel Farage explains the politics of Reform UK: Racism, Fake anti-establishmentism, Deregulation, Corporatism, Climate Change Denial, Mysogyny and Transphobia.
    Nigel Farage explains the politics of Reform UK: Racism, Fake anti-establishmentism, Deregulation, Corporatism, Climate Change Denial, Mysogyny and Transphobia.
  • Polanski accuses Labour of ‘running scared’ over Jackdaw drilling decision

    Spread the love

    https://morningstaronline.co.uk/article/zack-polanski-accuses-labour-running-scared-over-jackdaw-drilling-decision

     Green party leader Zack Polanski stands with party members at King’s Place in London, after he was picked as the Green Party candidate for the Holborn and St Pancras by-election, Friday September 11, 2026

    GREEN Party leader Zack Polanski accused Labour today of “running scared,” following reports that Prime Minister Andy Burnham will delay announcing his decision on drilling in the Jackdaw gas field until after the Holborn and St Pancras by-election.

    Mr Polanski, who was announced today as his party’s candidate in the election on October 8, said that Labour had “started the campaign with an act of dishonesty and betrayal.”

    He argued: “They are clearly going to allow new drilling in the North Sea but want to keep it under wraps during a byelection where they know the public want tougher action on climate, not backsliding.

    “Labour talks about change, but this is change for the worse. We have a climate crisis, but Labour is taking the side of fossil fuel corporations….”

    …

    Article continues at https://morningstaronline.co.uk/article/zack-polanski-accuses-labour-running-scared-over-jackdaw-drilling-decision

    UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham says that he's going to permit the Jackdaw and Rosebank North Sea fossil fuel projects. He urges you to ignore facts and reality and be a climate science denier like him
    UK Prime Minister Andy Burnham says that he’s going to permit the Jackdaw and Rosebank North Sea fossil fuel projects. He urges you to ignore facts and reality and be a climate science denier like him
    Nigel Farage urges you to ignore facts and reality and be a climate science denier like him and his Deputy Richard Tice. He says that Reform UK has received £Millions and £Millions from the fossil fuel industry to promote climate denial and destroy the planet.
    Nigel Farage urges you to ignore facts and reality and be a climate science denier like him and his Deputy Richard Tice. He says that Reform UK has received £Millions and £Millions from the fossil fuel industry to promote climate denial and destroy the planet.
    Donald Trump urges you to be a Climate Science denier like him. He says that he makes millions and millions for destroying the planet, Burn, Baby, Burn and Flood, Baby, Flood.
    Donald Trump urges you to be a Climate Science denier like him. He says that he makes millions and millions for destroying the planet, Burn, Baby, Burn and Flood, Baby, Flood.
  • Zack Polanski selected as Green Party candidate in Holborn and St Pancras byelection 

    Spread the love
    Green party leader Zack Polanski (Green Party of England and Wales). Image: Bristol Green Party Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication.
    Green party leader Zack Polanski (Green Party of England and Wales). Image: Bristol Green Party Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication.

    Green leader: “I love this place… I’ll fight for you.” 

    Zack Polanski was selected at a local party hustings last night (10 September). He will contest the Holborn and St Pancras byelection on the 8th October. The announcement was made by the Green Party this morning (11 September) at Kings Place in Camden. 

    Commenting on his selection, Zack Polanski said: 

    “I am proud and honoured to have been selected for a byelection in the constituency where I have lived and worked for much of the past 20 years. 

    “I love this place and so do the people whose doors I’ve knocked on in recent days – but it can be even better. I know times are tough in Holborn and St Pancras. My story of constant moving around flats is such a common story for Londoners – and I know many people here are really struggling right now. I’ll fight to turn this around. 

    “Greens are underdogs here but we have the momentum – and I know we can achieve a historic victory in one of Labour’s safest seats. We will fight a positive campaign on the issues we know people care about, and to put as much pressure as we can on Labour to lower bills, for much more affordable housing and rent controls, to reduce massive wealth inequality and to make sure Labour don’t back down on climate action by allowing more North Sea drilling. 

    “If elected, I will fight every day, in this constituency and in the Houses of Parliament, for the things people care about. Against injustice and on the side of ordinary people, not big money and the powerful.” 

  • Britain proud to be ‘showing leadership’ on Palestine, says Burnham

    Spread the love

    https://morningstaronline.co.uk/article/britain-leadership-palestine-israel-andy-burnham-middle-east

     Prime Minister Andy Burnham departs 10 Downing Street, London, to attend his first Prime Minister’s Questions at the Houses of Parliament, September 9, 2026

    BRITAIN is proud to be leading the way in challenging the Israeli occupation of Palestine, Prime Minister Andy Burnham told MPs today.

    Speaking in the Commons a day after Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband had announced sweeping sanctions against Israeli settlements and denounced terrorist “ethnic cleansing” in Palestine, Mr Burnham said: “Britain is showing leadership. 

    “Words from any politician about a two-state solution will be only words if it’s not backed with action. And leadership is about taking action.

    “Britain has to stand for something. Britain has to show leadership. Britain has to stand for fairness against injustice.

    “Where people are being bullied out of their homes, intimidated, we will always stand with the underdog and take what action we can to support them. 

    “That is leadership on the world stage, Britain being true to what it’s always been about.”

    Mr Miliband himself, basking in broad approval for his measures from Labour MPs for both his commitment to the new policy and for assembling support from France, Canada and elsewhere for it, brushed aside overwrought criticism of the sanctions from chief rabbi Ephraim Mirvis, who had claimed they were “a dark day for British Jews.”

    The Foreign Secretary said: “I’m a proud British Jew, and I don’t agree with the chief rabbi.

    “I believe that it must be possible to do what we did, which is to stand up for British values of the rule of law, of dignity for people, of the prevention of injustice, and do so in a way, as I did yesterday, to say to anyone in our country who holds British Jews responsible for the actions of the Israeli government, that is antisemitism, pure and simple.”

    He made it clear that British firms and potentially Israeli banks involved in the construction or financing of illegal West Bank settlements would be hit by the sanctions.

    “We are seeking to cut off the supply of the supply lines of British finance, British construction, for settlement expansion,” Mr Miliband said. 

    “This is about a clear purpose, which is to draw a line in the sand and to stop this infinite, ever-expanding settlement expansion.”

    He also shrugged off as “regrettable” counter-measures announced by the Netanyahu government, including the closing of the British consulate in Jerusalem and the banning of 11 MPs from visiting Israel.

    “I would prefer that Israel hadn’t announced what it did, but overall, I strongly believe that what we did, along with other international allies, was absolutely the right thing to do,” the Foreign Secretary said.

    The MPs sanctioned stressed it would change nothing in their attitudes and actions.

    Your Party parliamentary leader Jeremy Corbyn said in a statement: “I have visited all parts of Palestine on several occasions, where I have witnessed the horrors of occupation, as well as the resilience and humanity of the Palestinian people. 

    “They are the ones who suffer from Israel’s apartheid. 

    “Israel doesn’t want the world to see what it is doing — but we can never give up in our attempts to expose the truth. 

    “That is the real scandal. Israel’s genocide cannot go unpunished — and I will keep speaking up for peace, freedom and justice for the Palestinian people.”

    Fellow Your Party MP Zarah Sultana said: “Israel has just banned me from entering. 

    “Given that this is a fascist government presiding over genocide, apartheid and an illegal occupation, I’ll wear it as a badge of honour. 

    “I will not be intimidated into silence. I will continue to speak out against Israel’s genocide and against the UK’s complicity. If anything, this ban only strengthens my resolve to keep speaking out.”

    She added: “One day, I look forward to visiting Jerusalem not as an occupied city, but as part of a free and liberated Palestine.” 

    Bradford West MP Naz Shah called the list “rather random and, frankly, bizarre” and said she was “proud of the UK government’s actions today, taken in line with our international legal obligations.” 

    She pledged to continue to campaign for a two-state solution in Palestine. 

    Labour MPs John McDonnell, Diane Abbott and Richard Burgon were also on the list and all five Green MPs were sanctioned by Israel.

    The Green Party said: “We will not be bullied into silence by the Israeli government. 

    “We are proud of our MPs for standing up for Palestinian rights and demanding an end to British complicity in genocide and illegal occupation.

    “Banning our representatives only strengthens our resolve. The British government must stand firm and follow these overdue restrictions with a full arms embargo and wide-ranging sanctions.”

    https://morningstaronline.co.uk/article/britain-leadership-palestine-israel-andy-burnham-middle-east With thanks to Morning Star.