by Jasim Al-Azzawi

This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. 

The MAGA empire has turned inward. Its warriors no longer march shoulder to shoulder in lockstep but carve at one another like rival warlords. The movement that once roared in unison now splits along a single, explosive fault line: America First versus Israel First. Two convictions, two armies now face each other inside the same ideological fortress, each convinced it alone holds the mandate of destiny. On one side stands Steve Bannon — raw, furious, unapologetically nationalist. On the other stands Ben Shapiro — polished, venomous, the cultural enforcer of unyielding loyalty to Israel. The alliance that once dominated the American right is devouring itself at an increasing pace. What was once unfathomable is now undeniable: the eighty-year consensus that Israel dictates the boundaries of conservative politics is cracking apart, and the reverberating tremor is shaking the very columns of American power.

The explosion happened in public, not whispered in back rooms or podcasts, but detonated onstage at the first Turning Point USA conference after Charlie Kirk’s assassination. It should have been a sombre moment of unity. Instead, the air stiffened with accusations. Ben Shapiro, self-appointed guardian of ideological purity, initiated his scorched-earth tirade. Unabashedly, he fired the first salvo. He spat contempt at Tucker Carlson, Megyn Kelly, Candace Owens, and Steve Bannon himself. He called them “charlatans” and accused them of extremism. But beneath the theatrics lay the real crime he could not forgive; they dared even entertain the suggestion that American loyalty to Israel is not beyond question. The Israel First Rubicon had been crossed. And Shapiro — furious, brittle, panicked — declared ideological jihad.

Bannon’s deafening reply was not a rebuttal. It was a devastating indictment. He took the same stage and drove a sharp spike through the heart of the illusion that the American right still bows obediently and wholeheartedly before Israeli dictates. Shapiro, he roared, was “a cancer spreading through the body” of conservative politics — not simply wrong, but dangerous, parasitic, devouring the movement from within. This was not an improvised cable-show rhetoric. This was a declaration of civil war inside the American right. And Bannon knew precisely what he was doing and why. The skirmish is not about conference insults. It is about the 2028 presidential election, about power, about whether American nationalism means sovereignty… or subservience.

READ: Israeli army claims tens of thousands of Houthis are preparing attacks from neighbouring countries

The televised public fracture now bleeds into the rank and file. MAGA supporters are forced to choose: Is America sovereign, or is Israel sacred? For decades, that question, among the most critical questions of our time, was forbidden. To ask it was political suicide. To answer it honestly was exile. But history has a cruel habit of forcing buried truths to the surface. And Charlie Kirk — before his death — had already begun whispering those questions. The ghost of that defiance now stalks the movement that bears his name.

Bannon’s latest strident eruption tore the mask off entirely. With brutal clarity, he declared what Israeli leaders never believed they’d hear from their most powerful allies: Israel does not own American foreign policy anymore. He mocked Netanyahu’s protests of “partnership.” He described a protectorate, a client state, a vassal state, terrified of losing its grip instead. And Bannon claimed something far more astonishing — that Trump’s inner circle is already acting accordingly. He describes Kushner, Witkoff, Vance, Rubio negotiating with Qatar, Turkey, Egypt, the UAE — shaping Gaza’s future without asking Tel Aviv’s permission. Israel — long used to dictating American position — now finds itself abruptly sidelined, gripped by fear of being reduced to a secondary role.

Bannon pushed further still. He declared what Netanyahu and his supporters fear most: Israel’s Greater Israel fantasy has destroyed Israel. It overreached. It strangled itself by pursuing a repugnant occupation despised worldwide. The country now wails in rage as the leash slips. Israel is not ascendant. Israel is in the throes of death.

The break is not merely political. It is theological. Cultural. Civilizational.

Bannon predicts a tectonic reversal of a century of Middle Eastern geopolitical order. He claims the United States is unwinding, in months, what empires took decades to build. Turkey — once conquered, now returns. Regional states — Egypt, UAE, maybe even Saudi Arabia — are poised to define the future of Gaza. Hamas may fade into irrelevance. Israel screams in protest. And Washington shrugs and walks away.

OPINION: The cracks in MAGA: the American right is divided over the Middle East

His most explosive idea lands like a theological bombshell: a three-state solution that includes a Christian sovereign stake in Jerusalem. Not symbolism. Not rhetoric. Power. Security. Permanence. Something neither Israel nor Palestinians want even to imagine… but something Bannon argues the world will now impose.

The verdict is merciless: Israel no longer dictates terms. It receives them. Accept the regional future… or walk alone. No money. No arms. No shield. Israeli exceptionalism — once unquestioned gospel in Washington — now may become a relic with time.

The reaction from Israel’s defenders is predictable and frantic. Tucker Carlson is crowned “Antisemite of the Year” by StopAntisemitism, a desperate, brutal attempt to enforce obedience through public shaming. Once, this label would have destroyed a career. Now? It engenders laughter and ridicule. It is worn as a badge of defiance within the America First camp—a signal that a new right exists, a new era has begun—one that refuses to kneel.

This is not a policy debate. This is an ideological exorcism. The American right is purging something that has dominated it for generations. And the fight will be savage and relentless.

The MAGA movement now stands at an existential crossroads. One road leads back to submission — back to the politics of obligation, automatic military aid, unconditional diplomatic protection, the eternal promise that America’s destiny is forever chained to Tel Aviv’s agenda. The other road is brutal, nationalist, and unapologetically self-interested. America First, without disclaimers. America First, without foreign veto. America First, without fear.

The knives are drawn. The war has begun. And the world will watch a battle like no other. 

And when the shouting ends, when the slogans fade, when the smoke clears over this ideological battlefield, one truth will remain: American conservatism will never return to what it was… and Israel will never again command what it once did.

OPINION: America’s double game with international justice: When power poses as principle

The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.

This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.