Two scorpions in a jar
This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
Trump and Netanyahu need each other more than they trust each other — and that mutual need, not any shared conviction, is the only thing still holding the alliance together.
There is an old parable about two scorpions in a jar. Neither can leave. Neither trusts the other. And sooner or later, one strikes, not because it wants to kill the other, but because the jar has become unbearable.
Donald Trump and Benjamin Netanyahu are those scorpions now, and the jar is the wreckage of the Middle East they built together.
For the better part of a year, they marched in locked steps. One man’s appetite for spectacle matched by the other’s genius for making disaster look like deliverance. Netanyahu persuaded Trump that Iran could be shattered quickly, cleanly, at no real cost. Trump believed him because believing him was easier than doubting him, and doubt has never been a currency Trump trades in. The war came. But Iran did not break. And when the bill arrived, it was delivered to Trump’s door, not Netanyahu’s.
John Mearsheimer of the University of Chicago, who has spent a career mapping the architecture of American deference to Israeli interests, put the verdict as bluntly as a man of his discipline allows:
Netanyahu convinced Trump the war would be short and decisive, and Trump, in Mearsheimer’s words, was foolish enough to believe him.
Elsewhere, Mearsheimer has been blunter still, arguing flatly that Israel and its lobby own Trump,
and that the President has demonstrated, repeatedly, a willingness to dance to Jerusalem’s tune.
Then came Lebanon, and with it the profanity that told the truth polite diplomacy never does. Reports of a fifteen-minute call, confirmed by Trump himself, describe the President screaming at Netanyahu, demanding to know what the hell he was doing. He called Netanyahu “crazy,” reminded him that he would be sitting in prison were it not for American protection, and scolded him in the most excruciating language, that the world now despised him for it. This is not the language of alliance. It is the language of a landlord screaming at a tenant who has torched the building and still expects a reference letter.
Monsters playing victims: Danny Danon’s twisted war on the truth
Netanyahu absorbed the insult silently, the way he absorbs everything, with a statement insisting nothing had changed, that Israel’s “position remains the same,” even as his troops turned back from Beirut on Trump’s order. One American official described the call more crudely: Trump had steamrolled him, and all the great warrior-statesman could manage in reply was a chastened “OK, OK”. This isn’t how empires normally treat client states, but this was never a partnership of equals. It is, as Jeffrey Sachs of Columbia University observes, the latest chapter in a decades-long bid for regional dominance. In this script, Netanyahu and the architects of Greater Israel are the sole victors; everyone else is left with the ashes. Sachs does not flinch from naming the architecture. The war on Iran, he argues, was never separate from the older “Clean Break” doctrine first sketched in 1996, a blueprint for regime-change wars with Washington cast as the enforcement arm of Israeli strategy. In that reading, Trump is not a partner but an instrument, wielded by a prime minister facing indictment at home and a coalition that cannot survive a genuine peace.
Gideon Levy of Haaretz, writing from inside Israel’s collapsing consensus, sees the same rot from the other direction. He has warned that Israel follows Netanyahu mindlessly toward a reckoning it has not yet allowed itself to imagine, and that the U.S.-Israel relationship itself is nearing its breaking point. Even Thomas Friedman, hardly a radical, has confessed to being torn, rooting against the Iranian regime while dreading what its defeat would do for two men, he flatly calls terrible people, “alleged crooks” running “anti-democratic projects” in their own countries.
Phyllis Bennis of Institute for Policy Studies frames the arrangement in the coldest terms available: not statesmanship, but real-estate logic: a transactional partnership between a president with no re-election ahead of him but a legacy to launder, and a prime minister facing an October election and a courtroom he has spent years trying to outrun.
Both men need a win they cannot contrive through governance, so they manufacture it through war. Both are impeachable, indictable, and disposable to the very coalitions that elevated them.
AIPAC, the Israeli religious right, and the Republican Zionist bloc in the U.S. Senate are Netanyahu’s insurance policy. Miriam Adelson’s checkbook and the MAGA base are Trump’s. Each man is one betrayal away from being fed to those bases as a sacrifice, and each of them knows it.
This is why the scorpion metaphor holds. Two men who need each other to survive politically are also the two men most capable of mortally stinging each other. Trump has already shown he will humiliate Netanyahu the moment the war stops being useful to him. Netanyahu has already shown he will defy Trump’s orders the moment his coalition demands it. The sting, when it finally comes, will not be ideological. It will be self-preservation, dressed up as principle, in a jar built from the bones of Lebanon, Gaza, and Iran, while the region, and the truth, are left to rot in the glass along with them.
READ: Pepe, Pakistan, and the last of the great foreign correspondents
The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.
This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
- Iranian president criticises international silence over Israeli actions
- Israeli strike kills Palestinian in Gaza as army continues demolitions
- Lebanon says 400,000 displaced people have returned south as government prepares reconstruction plan
- Medvedev says Strait of Hormuz gives Iran leverage comparable to ‘nuclear weapon’
- Israeli intelligence rejects Netanyahu’s request to back claim Iran’s nuclear program was completely destroyed: Report
- Iran rejects UK-France Hormuz statement, warns against foreign military presence
- Egypt celebrates historic first-ever World Cup Round of 16 qualification
- Rights center documents 83 Israeli attacks on Christians in 3 months, mostly in occupied Jerusalem
- Two scorpions in a jar
- The funeral that reveals a world divided
- The geopolitics of energy storage: Who will control the batteries of the Middle East?
- Israeli army confirms authenticity of image showing Palestinian detainee abused in Gaza
- Israeli army disperses protest in southern West Bank, injures, arrests Palestinians
- Israeli drone strikes injure 2 in southern Lebanon despite framework agreement
- Israeli spyware used against ex-Greek MEP during probe of illegal surveillance: Report
- Gulf states express solidarity with Syria after deadly Damascus cafe bombing
- UAE thwarts ‘sophisticated’ cyberattacks targeting financial sector
- Israeli army ends Givati Brigade mission in southern Lebanon after 8 months
- Australian police review war crime allegations against citizen as war in Gaza crosses 1000th day
- China calls for ‘proper settlement’ to end disruptions in Strait of Hormuz
- Israel approves 13 new illegal settlements as Palestinians warn of Jerusalem’s further isolation
- One thousand days of war: Why Israel failed to defeat Palestine
- 1,022 infants among more than 21,500 children killed during Gaza’s 1,000-day war
- West African states begin withdrawal from ICC
- Google disrupts Israel-linked proxy network used to spread malware
- Israel says 26,000 troops treated since Gaza war began, most for psychological conditions
- Israel planned to target Iranian negotiators to derail talks, US acted to prevent it – report
- France, Italy to form new international force for southern Lebanon
- Iran tells UN it will guarantee safe passage through Strait of Hormuz for 60 days
- Egypt and Turkey sign agreement to enhance cooperation on strategic transport corridors
- Demonstrators in Paris stage silent march over 1,000 days of genocide in Gaza
- Palestinian Foreign Ministry denies claims it asked South Africa to withdraw ICJ case against Israel
- Syria reassures Lebanon it has no intention of military intervention
- Berri warns Israel is seeking to provoke conflict between Lebanese army and Hezbollah
- Hamas official reveals more than 3,500 Israeli ceasefire violations in Gaza
- Great power competition under Trump: The Greenland crisis as a case study
- Israel tightens solitary confinement of jailed Fatah leader Marwan Barghouti, his office says
- Rouzaina… the true face of Syria
- 6 killed, 22 injured in bomb explosion at cafe in Syrian capital
- Syrian Airlines launches first flight from Amsterdam to Damascus after years of suspension, media says
- Israeli army raids city in northern occupied West Bank, closes main roads
- Iranian parliament speaker calls for public turnout at former supreme leader’s funeral
- US, Iran expected to hold direct talks in Doha in 3rd week of July: Sources
- US fighter jets presence over Hormuz threatens regional security: Iranian army
- At least 21,000 children killed in Gaza after 1,000 days of war, Save the Children says
- Palestine solidarity takes center stage throughout 2026 FIFA World Cup
- 1,000 days of Israel’s genocide: Gaza children get killed, orphaned and starved
- UK MPs warn platforming Pahlavi risks replacing ‘one form of authoritarian rule with another’
- What Recent Democratic Primaries Reveal About the 2024 DNC Autopsy?
- Press freedom group moves to quell outrage over fears Gaza journalists could be delisted
