This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
The EU, as well as individual European countries, have criticised Israel’s forced entry at the Qalandia Vocational Training Centre and the seizure of UNRWA’s installations in East Jerusalem. In a statement that reads as futile as any other, Israel was urged to “honour its obligations and to halt all disruptions to UNRWA’s activities and operations without delay.”
Israel’s response was typical – according to its Foreign Ministry, the EU and individual European countries are supporting “an organisation that is a breeding ground for terrorism.” Terrorism, according to Israel, was the reason UNRWA was banned from operating in the occupied Palestinian territories. It referenced a recent US Agency for International Development report which stated that over 100 current or former UNRWA staff members participated in the October 7 incursion into Israel.
The bottom line is that Israel has made no secret out of wanting to eradicate UNRWA, while the EU, like the rest of the international community wants to maintain the humanitarian paradigm as it serves the purpose of not addressing the Palestinian people’s political rights.
Yet, while serving a diplomatic purpose by speaking on UNRWA’s behalf, the support does not extend to the Palestinian people. A temporary organisation cannot serve a permanent purpose. The EU and the international community know the limitations UNRWA faces; both know that even financially, UNRWA can never deliver the standard required for the Palestinian people’s autonomy and independence. Politically, UNRWA has become embroiled in the politics of maintaining the Palestinian people’s refugee status, because the international community has completely rejected decolonisation.
READ: Israel bolsters forces at seized UNRWA training center in occupied Jerusalem
The EU, like the international community, plays a duplicitous role when it comes to UNRWA and the Palestinian people. Israel was asked to ‘honour its obligations’. Yet taking into account recent history, where was the EU when Palestinians were being massacred in Israel’s genocide in Gaza?
Was the EU not obliged to honour its obligations and work towards ending the genocide, instead of working to create more cycles of forced displacement by giving Israel absolute impunity?
Since the EU, alongside the international community, allowed Israel to continue its genocide, which aspect of UNRWA is it really supporting? The existence of the organisation, or the limited work UNRWA was accomplishing for Palestinian refugees due to the international community’s refusal to acknowledge the colonial politics of forced displacement?
If UNRWA and its work were truly considered a priority, the EU would not work against the institution and pretend to support it only when Israel commits a violation that cannot be diplomatically ignored. The EU’s support for UNRWA would have included the bloc taking a stance against genocide and forced displacement, rather than approving of the massacres by upholding Israel’s security narrative. Eliminating UNRWA, or shutting down its operations, will not make the refugees disappear. If, however, the EU tackled genocide and forced displacement both from the human and the political aspect, UNRWA could have been slightly helped, while more Palestinians would have been saved.
Israel will not honour its obligations, of course. But neither does the EU. If saving UNRWA and Palestinians refugees were truly a priority, the EU would have avoided complicity in the genocide in Gaza. Obligations, therefore, need to be defined, as they sit in blurred parameters when the EU asks Israel to abide by international law while collaborating in maintaining the perpetual displacement of Palestinian refugees.
BLOG: International condemnation of settlements does not target Israel’s colonial plan
The views expressed in this article belong to the author and do not necessarily reflect the editorial policy of Middle East Monitor.
This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.
- Saudi Arabia committed to activating Mecca defense pact mechanisms: Defense minister
- 1,014 Palestinian athletes killed by Israel during Gaza genocide: Sports official
- US interested in ‘continuing war,’ Iranian president says in talks with India’s Modi
- Israel establishes new illegal settlement southeast of Jenin in occupied West Bank
- 56 days before Israeli elections, Prime Minister Netanyahu grows weaker: Analysis
- Mecca defense agreement launches process for ‘new regional security, cooperation architecture’: Turkish foreign minister
- Trump calls for war crimes trial of Iranian leadership over alleged protesters’ deaths
- Israeli army demolishes 3 Palestinian buildings, detains 7 in West Bank
- Iraqi premier rejects proposal to keep some international coalition forces beyond Sept. 30
- Scottish government urged to fully implement sanctions against Israel
- Israel, Greece sign €3B defense deal for ‘multi-layered’ air defense network
- Israeli police clash with ultra-Orthodox Jew protesters over military service
- US to respond to Iranian attacks on forces in Middle East: Trump
- Iran says US strikes on Kharg Island did not stop oil production
- The Israeli occupation forces struck a car in the Tal al-Hawa area, west of Gaza City, resulting in casualties
- Former Israeli premier says Israel associated with ‘genocide’ among US students
- Washington has two failed peace deals and both failed the same way
- Finnish opposition party calls extension of defence deal with Israel a “historic shame”
- US deports dozens to Central African Republic, including Afghan man who aided US military
- Israeli rabbi calls for Palestinians’ expulsion from occupied West Bank
- Erdogan: Turkish army is going through its strongest period
- The EU’s complicity with Israel renders support for UNRWA negligible
- Lebanon welcomes Araghchi, urges Iran to deal with state institutions
- Smotrich calls for removal of 40 Palestinian memorials in West Bank within 24 hours
- Israeli media: Senior RSF commander Abdel Rahim Dagalo secretly visited Israel
- Report: Turkish warships force Israeli naval vessels to alter course in Mediterranean
- Report: Turkey, Saudi Arabia and Pakistan to hold first meeting under Joint Defence Agreement
- Settlers begin infrastructure work at outpost east of Bethlehem
- Iran fires missiles from multiple locations toward regional targets: Report
- Ben-Gvir’s visit to Palestinian female prisoners’ cells draws criticism
- Oil tanker hit by unidentified projectile off Oman: UKMTO
- US strikes Iranian launchers on Larak Island, marking first attacks in weeks
- Podcast by Jasim Al-Azzawi with Kelley Beaucar Vlahos:The D-Day Sanctions Against Iran: Will They Work or Backfire?
- Iran says it controls Strait of Hormuz and has stopped 30 ships from crossing
- Islamabad, Riyadh agree to boost Pakistani agriculture and food exports to $3B in 2 years
- Turkiye mobilised all resources after passenger ship capsize off Northern Cyprus: President Erdogan
- Culinary larceny: Why the true history of Palestine belongs to the soil, not the Israeli kitchen
- Israel’s national security minister ‘pleased’ with harsh conditions of Palestinian prisoners
- Nearly 20,000 people displaced by escalating fighting in Sudan’s Blue Nile: Local group
- Masked Israeli occupiers attack Palestinian woman, NBC News crew in occupied West Bank
- Gaza families seek the fate of relatives missing during the war on International Day of the Disappeared
- Rulers of Muslim nations should recognise ‘true enemy,’ says Iran’s supreme leader
- Egypt’s apparatus of enforced disappearance must be halted – Silence by BRICS and AU not an option
- FEDA calls on Egypt authorities to reveal the fate of those forcibly disappeared
- Iran’s parliament speaker rejects US Treasury chief’s claims over economic pressure
- Houthis announce death of 2 officers in clashes with government forces
- Demonstrators gather in Stockholm to protest Israel’s Gaza attacks
- 3 Palestinians killed, 7 injured in Israeli attacks across Gaza despite ceasefire
- 14 Palestinians, 2 foreign journalists injured in attacks by Israeli army, occupiers in occupied West Bank
- Pro-Palestinian protesters march in Paris with olive branches and kites
Leave a Reply