





https://morningstaronline.co.uk/article/zombie-blairites-cant-fix-youth-unemployment-crisis

…
The findings of Milburn’s inquiry will be used as the pretext for an even harsher benefits regime that targets the most vulnerable people in our communities, people who genuinely cannot work. The interim report includes plans to cut the overall cash benefit payment in order to fund youth employment schemes, creating a false dichotomy between investing in the day-to-day existence of disabled people and the futures of young people.
Another of Milburn’s proposals is for children from the poorest areas to be identified as economic failures from pre-school age. This will only extend the stigmatisation of vulnerable groups. In addition, the idea that young mothers should be classed in the data as economically inactive or unproductive is blind to the fact that unpaid social reproductive labour is the backbone of the economy.
Decades of austerity have shown you can’t cut your way out of a crisis. The New Labour tribute act in Westminster isn’t up to the task of solving the youth unemployment crisis.
…
https://morningstaronline.co.uk/article/zombie-blairites-cant-fix-youth-unemployment-crisis




Article by Ethan Shone republished from OpenDemocracy under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International licence.

Soon after Morgan McSweeney left Downing Street this February in the wake of the Peter Mandelson scandal, he told the BBC he was “committing to being out of politics” for the next few years. By August however, the chief architect of Keir Starmer’s ill-fated tenure as Prime Minister had established his own firm, McSweeney Advisory, which will offer strategic advice on politics.
McSweeney isn’t the only Starmerite alumni to set up their own ‘one-man-band’ advisory firms, openDemocracy can reveal.
After pledging to reform lobbying and clean-up money in politics, the so-called Starmer-project has spawned a mini-cottage industry of consultants and advisors, that includes Baroness Martin, a former top adviser to Starmer’s chancellor Rachel Reeves and Starmer’s former communications’ director Ben Nunn.
The irony is not lost on Labour veterans.
“They waged a dirty tricks campaign to take control of the party, then wasted a massive opportunity. Meanwhile we’re still here, in government, fighting for working people and trying to clean up the mess they left, while they swan off to coin it in the City,” as one staffer said, adding that these advisers are now being rewarded “not for failure, but for doing what their corporate backers wanted the whole time”.
Transparency activists and anti-corruption activists, meanwhile, describe the current lobbying rules as “pitiful”, with past research estimating that the current framework captures less than 1% of the actual lobbying which takes place in Westminster.
Advisory firms often fall outside the narrow legislative definition of ‘consultant lobbying’. Rather than contacting ministers directly on behalf of their clients (which could trigger transparency legislation), these firms skirt the rules by offering paid-for-advice to their clients on how to interact with the government, or how to pursue their policy goals based on the deep knowledge the advisors have acquired over years spent in party politics and in government.
Campaigners have warned that the current lobbying rules also mean that small firms of this type are well-suited to make use of a loophole which means that, even if they do carry out work which meets the narrow definition of consultant lobbying, they still may never have to register or declare their clients.
This loophole in the Lobbying Act, known as the so-called ‘VAT exemption’, means a company or individual is not required to register as a consultant lobbyist – no matter how much actual lobbying they do which would otherwise meet the statutory definition – if they are not a VAT registered business.
In the past, this has meant that MPs have been let off for breaching lobbying rules, because they are not VAT registered businesses, or that major lobbying firms, like the now-defunct Global Counsel, have not been required to register clients that have been billed through their overseas subsidiaries.
MPs and campaigners have also highlighted how this exemption means relatively small businesses whose turnover is less than the VAT threshold of £90,000 are not required to register. In practice this means that an individual lobbyist who sets up a company to serve one or two large clients could still carry out a significant amount of paid lobbying without ever needing to register.
Such flaws in the Lobbying Act are so self-evident that even industry representative bodies for the lobbying industry itself are in favour of a stricter, more comprehensive system to regulate the industry.
Senior campaign lead at Spotlight on Corruption Kamila Kingstone told openDemocracy: “The fact that even powerful and influential consultant lobbyists can get away with not putting their name on the lobbying register highlights the pitiful state of the UK’s lobbying rules.
“Experts have repeatedly pointed out that the VAT exemption is a massive loophole, but successive governments have repeatedly ignored it.”
Senior advisers that leave government to take up private sector roles must get sign-off from the Civil Service Commission, which assesses potential conflicts of interest and imposes conditions on their employment – though in practice the commission has no formal powers to investigate or enforce these rules.
When openDemocracy reached out to McSweeney, he said his firm offers “strategic advice and analysis on political developments, geopolitics, democratic security and related issues”.
“My work involves helping organisations understand political and geopolitical developments, not seeking to influence government decisions on their behalf,” he said.
Rachel Reeves’ top adviser throughout her time as shadow chancellor and in government has also set up shop as a corporate adviser, establishing Katie Martin Advisory earlier this year, despite sitting in the House of Lords as a serving peer.
The now-ennobled Baroness Martin of Brockley had as much influence over and insight into Starmerism’s economic platform as any other adviser in government. She also led on business engagement, developing relationships with City firms and other major Treasury stakeholders.
In addition, Baroness Martin has taken up a senior advisory role with Peel Hunt, an investment bank she met with several times in office, and will support the bank to develop relationships with ministers, while sitting as a peer in the House of Lords.
According to correspondence published by the Civil Service Commission, Baroness Martin “will advise Peel Hunt’s leadership on brand and positioning to expand their presence in the UK” but will also advise on “how to strengthen relationships with officials, ministers and regional leaders in government”. Baroness Martin told the commission she “would not facilitate these relationships personally” and confirmed her role “will not involve contact with, or lobbying of, government”.
Baroness Martin met with Peel Hunt formally twice in government and acknowledged she had likely met representatives of the bank a further “two or three times at events”. She was also involved in conversations about London IPOs, a policy area she acknowledged Peel Hunt “had an interest in”. Her new job includes supporting the bank’s “emerging work with the London Stock Exchange to encourage more companies to launch on the UK stock market”.
Alongside her advisory work Baroness Martin has also joined the board of ThinkLabour, the organisation formerly known as Labour Together; the Commission approved the unpaid role on 8 October. She sits on the board alongside veteran finance lobbyist Mike Craven, founder of public affairs agency Lexington.
Beyond McSweeney and Baroness Martin, few figures have been as close to the Starmer project for as long as Ben Nunn. He was Starmer’s communications director in opposition, then Reeves’. He left the party to work for Lexington for a time, then returned in November 2025 to replace Baroness Martin as Reeves’ chief of staff, staying until the project’s collapse in July.
He is now sole director of Arlington Road Consultants, a political advisory seemingly named after the “Arlington Road” group that plotted to oust Jeremy Corbyn and install Starmer as Labour leader.
Earlier this month, the Mail on Sunday reported that Nunn and Reeves had met two City firms days before the Budget, to discuss “the political advice the pair could offer”. Sources told the paper that both chief executives had met Reeves several times while she was Chancellor. The Conservative chairman, Kevin Hollinrake, has asked the independent adviser on ministerial standards to investigate.
In response to the Mandelson scandal, Starmer’s No10 commissioned the Ethics and Integrity Commission (EIC) to produce the latest in a long series of independent reviews into lobbying reform which reported back earlier this year.
Starmer’s administration did not act on the EIC’s recommendations, though they came not long before he was ousted by Andy Burnham, whose administration is yet to commit to any reform.
Kingstone and other campaigners have urged the government to look seriously at the recommendations put forward by the EIC, including to broaden out the statutory definition of consultant lobbying to capture a much wider range of activity.
She said: “The government needs to accept the Ethics and Integrity Commission’s recommendations to require all lobbyists to have to register on a comprehensive transparency portal – whatever their tax arrangements – so that the public can see who is meeting the government, who they are representing, and what they are discussing”
McSweeney told openDemocracy: “I do not provide lobbying services, nor do I intend to.”
“I therefore have no plans to register as a consultant lobbyist, as that is not the business I conduct. The suggestion that my company is well-placed to exploit a loophole in lobbying legislation is misleading. I have no intention of using any such loophole.”
openDemocracy contacted Baroness Martin and Ben Nunn with questions about the nature of their work, but had received no response at time of publication.
Article by Ethan Shone republished from OpenDemocracy under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International licence.


This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

BBC News presenters repeatedly put Israel’s position to guests who criticised its conduct in Gaza, but rarely put the Palestinian position to guests who defended Israel, a new study of three years of the corporation’s coverage of the Gaza genocide has found.
The study, BBC: The Would Say Files, was published on 5 November by the media monitoring platform NewsCord and written by Nima Akram. It examined broadcast interviews and written articles from October 2023 to this month.
The researchers searched the subtitles of more than 51,000 BBC News channel programmes for phrases such as ‘Israel would say’, then checked each result by hand to confirm that a presenter was putting one side’s position to a guest from the other side.
The BBC Israel Would Say Files. The full results are in for both broadcast and articles.
— NewsCord (@newscord_org) November 10, 2026
Analysis of 267 broadcast interviews between October 2023 and October 2026:
– BBC presenters put Israel's case, in Israel's name, to guests criticising Israel's conduct in Gaza in 252… pic.twitter.com/xZ5kKGvP2v
Of 267 such interviews, BBC presenters put Israel’s case to critics of Israel in 252. They put the Palestinian case to Israel’s defenders in 15. The plainest form, “Israel would say”, was put to critics in 75 interviews, while “Palestinians would say”, or the same phrase naming any Palestinian group, was put to defenders in four.
NewsCord has compiled clips of these exchanges to show the scale of the gap. Its compilation of BBC presenters putting Israel’s case runs to 48 minutes and 12 seconds. The compilation of presenters putting the Palestinian case runs to 2 minutes and 38 seconds.
The study also found that the Palestinian case almost disappeared from BBC interviews after the first weeks of the genocide. Ten of the 15 cases came in the six weeks after 7 October 2023, and only five in the three years that followed. Presenters were still putting Israel’s case to its critics in 2026. NewsCord says this points to an editorial shift, in which the BBC stopped conveying what Palestinians were saying but continued to tell audiences what “Israel would say”.
READ: Lewis Hamilton visits Rafah crossing to see Egypt’s aid operation for Gaza
The same imbalance appeared in the BBC’s written coverage. In 1,618 articles, when the BBC reported criticism of Israel’s conduct in Gaza, it added Israel’s position 49 per cent of the time (1,771 of 3,648 claims). When it reported Israel’s claims, it added a Palestinian or UN position 38 per cent of the time (914 of 2,431), and a Palestinian position alone only 25 per cent of the time.
The gap was wider when the researchers compared official sources. When the authorities in Gaza made a claim against Israel, the BBC added Israel’s response 58 per cent of the time (334 of 575). When the Israeli government or army made a claim, it added a Palestinian or UN position 39 per cent of the time (855 of 2,165).
Looked at article by article, 71 per cent of articles reporting criticism of Israel gave Israel’s position at least once, compared with 53 per cent of articles reporting Israel’s claims that gave a Palestinian or UN position. NewsCord said this means Israel’s claims went entirely unchallenged in almost half of the articles in which it made them.
The study cites a ruling by the BBC’s Executive Complaints Unit on an interview broadcast on 3 November 2023. In that ruling, the unit defended putting opposing views to public figures, saying this does not mean an interviewer endorses them. NewsCord’s findings question whether that principle has been applied equally to both sides. The full report, including every broadcast and article in the study, is free to read online.
The findings add to a growing body of evidence on the BBC’s coverage of Palestine. In 2024, a study by the Centre for Media Monitoring found that British media consistently favoured Israeli narratives over Palestinian perspectives in the first month of the genocide. An investigation by journalist Owen Jones, based on interviews with 13 current and former BBC journalists, described how senior figures skewed coverage in Israel’s favour and ignored internal complaints. The BBC also faced criticism for declining to air Gaza: Medics Under Fire, a documentary on attacks on Palestinian healthcare workers. More than 600 media figures signed a letter in 2025 urging the corporation to broadcast it.
WATCH: AIPAC is losing its grip on Washington | Palestine This Week
This work by Middle East Monitor is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.


