Governments Must Tackle Climate Disinformation, Experts Urge

Spread the love

Original article by Joey Grostern republished from DeSmog.

Scientists and campaigners are calling on governments and tech companies to tackle climate disinformation. Credit: MauriceNorbert via Alamy

An open letter from climate scientists and campaigners warns of the dangers associated with false climate claims.

Governments around the world must take “immediate and decisive action” to tackle climate disinformation, scientists and campaign groups have urged as talks at the COP29 climate summit in Baku, Azerbaijan enter their fourth day. 

A coalition of 55 climate information integrity groups and 42 leading climate scientists and experts have signed an open letter urging countries to counter the risk of false and misleading claims that are wrecking efforts to slow climate change. 

It comes two days after UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer spoke at COP29 arguing that “there is no national security without climate security” – and a week after the election in the United States of Donald Trump, who has previously called climate change a “hoax”. 

The letter published today – signatories to which include Friends of the Earth, the Institute of Strategic Dialogue, and regional branches of Greenpeace and WWF – lists steps governments could take. 

These include adopting a universal definition of climate disinformation, such as the working definition proposed by the Climate Action Against Disinformation (CAAD) coalition, another signatory. 

According to the letter, the definition should cover anything that misrepresents scientific data or “falsely publicises” supposed solutions to climate change which in fact contribute to global warming, often referred to as “greenwashing”. 

Such a definition should cover “deceptive or misleading online behaviour” that undermines public understanding of climate change, the fact it is caused by human activity, and the need for urgent mitigation and adaptation action, the letter said. 

Signatories also urged governments to take action against organisations which give a platform to climate disinformation – including social media outlets, advertising technology providers, broadcasters, and publishing companies. 

“The spread of disinformation continues to undermine and delay our collective ability to act, jeopardising progress at crucial negotiations and the upcoming G20 Summit in Brazil”, the letter said.  

“Climate disinformation, waged by vested interests, undermines climate action and puts our collective future at risk. Our information ecosystem is being damaged, and those responsible must be held accountable.”

The letter ends by arguing that “by adopting these principles, governments can foster a healthier and safer online environment that supports informed decision-making and enables effective climate action.”

The world’s leading climate science group, the UN’s Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), has warned that efforts to tackle climate change were being delayed by “rhetoric and misinformation that undermines climate science and disregards risk and urgency”.

“As disinformation continues to be an obstacle to vital climate action, the message from this open letter to decision makers globally is clear: protecting truth in the climate conversation is critical if we are to secure meaningful change”, said Max MacBride, Head of Counter-Disinformation at Roots Greenpeace, the NGO’s grassroots campaign initiative.

“At Roots, we see every day how climate disinformation stifles youth advocacy, and we join this call to hold governments and platforms accountable for enabling informed, equitable climate action”, he said.

Climate Disinformation Threats 

A CAAD report published earlier this week found that climate disinformation is widespread online, and is hobbling efforts to address climate change. 

The report said that social media platforms bear responsibility for allowing “super spreaders” to “pollute their platforms with debunked claims attacking renewable energy and electric vehicles”.

CAAD also found that fossil fuel companies were allowed to use digital advertising across Meta platforms to greenwash their reputations, by promoting false solutions or presenting fossil fuels as essential to the energy transition. 

A study published in February found that 14 percent of Americans don’t believe climate change is real – even as growing numbers of Americans say they are concerned about the climate.

“In the US, we’ve painfully experienced the role disinformation has played in thwarting disaster response and threats to the lives of responders”, Kate Cell, Senior Climate Campaign Manager at the Union of Concerned Scientists, told DeSmog.

“As climate-fueled disasters become more common around the world, governments can protect their residents by addressing the problem of climate disinformation systemically.” 

Another report released this week by the scrutiny NGO InfluenceMap found 2.500 cases of fossil fuel companies pushing arguments which contradict IPCC recommendations since COP28 last year. 

Thais Lazzeri, founder of educational group FALA, a signatory to the letter, told DeSmog: “The letter comes at a unique time for Brazil, which is hosting the G20 and the incoming COP30 Presidency. The alliance of so many Brazilian institutes and professionals shows the urgency for answers and the intersectoral power of this Brazilian network, willing to work together.”

She added: “At the opening of the Brazil space at CO29, Environment Minister, Marina Silva, said that denialism doesn’t fit. The Brazilian government can lead by example and guarantee information integrity policies and strategic, connected actions to change the game.”

DeSmog has previously reported on news media spreading false climate claims, with The Telegraph newspaper in the UK attacking climate solutions – a trend that has increasing since July’s general election. As revealed by DeSmog in 2023, one in three presenters on the right-wing broadcaster GB News had spread climate disinformation during the previous year. 

“It is much easier to pollute the waters of public discussion on climate change causes and consequences than it is to keep them clean and productive,” said Max Boykoff, signatory to the letter and professor of Environmental Studies at Boulder University in Colorado and founder of the Media Climate Change Observatory, a project which analyses mentions of climate change in news media.

“Therefore, more proactive, clear, accurate and effective communication efforts are consistently and repeatedly needed. That motivates this call for government action to curb disinformation about climate change.”

Original article by Joey Grostern republished from DeSmog.

Related: UK & Government Petitions: Run a public information campaign on the climate crisis

Continue ReadingGovernments Must Tackle Climate Disinformation, Experts Urge

Meta and Koch Industries to Sponsor Event Featuring Climate Denier Barry Cooper 

Spread the love

Original article by Geoff Dembicki republished from DeSmog.

Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg pledged $33 million to fight climate change in 2021. Credit: Anthony Quintano / Wikimedia Commons

Chris Rufo, the conservative activist who created a moral panic around ‘critical race theory,’ is headlining.

Meta CEO Mark Zuckerberg has called climate change “one of the most urgent challenges of our time” and pledged tens of millions of dollars to help fight it.

Yet his company Meta, the owner of Facebook and Instagram, is listed as a “gold sponsor” for an event in Alberta next month featuring Barry Cooper, a University of Calgary political scientist who’s argued that there is “growing scientific skepticism” about whether humans are causing the climate to warm. 

Another gold sponsor is Koch Industries, the oil and gas company whose billionaire owner Charles Koch, along with his late brother David, has given more than $100 million since 1997 to organizations that dispute or deny climate science, according to Greenpeace calculations. 

The event is headlined by Chris Rufo, the U.S. conservative activist who created a moral panic around “critical race theory” and has argued that “transgenderism” is “threatening families and kids all over the United States.”

“It’s pretty unusual,” Sean Buchan, a researcher with the organization Climate Action Against Disinformation (CAAD), said of Meta’s sponsorship. “They generally speaking do their best to have a clean public image. These are some pretty toxic brands to be associated with.”

Meta didn’t reply to detailed questions from DeSmog. 

Chris Rufo leads an ongoing culture war against diversity and inclusion. Credit: Stanford Classical Liberalism Initiative

Rufo Influenced Donald Trump

The event, which takes place September 21, is a regional networking conference for the Canada Strong and Free Network, an organization committed to building the country’s conservative movement. “We aim to delve deep into the foundational principles that have shaped our nation and its conservative values,” a description of the conference reads

Rufo, the keynote speaker, is advertised as being “a prominent figure in the fight against critical race theory in American institutions.” His activism reportedly helped inspire President Donald Trump to sign an executive order banning racial sensitivity training in federal institutions. 

The Southern Poverty Law Center describes Rufo as a leader “in the right-wing anti-LGBTQ+ culture war.” And the Guardian reported earlier this year that he maintains a close relationship with a rightwing magazine called IM-1776 that “regularly showers praise on dictators and authoritarians, puffs racist ideologues, and attacks liberal democracy.”

University of Calgary political scientist Barry Cooper has argued there is ‘growing scientific skepticism’ about human-caused warming. Credit: Conversations That Matter

Denying Climate Since 2005

He’ll be joined at the event by Cooper, a longtime climate change denier. Cooper was involved with the release of a 23-minute video from 2005 entitled “Climate Catastrophe Cancelled: What You’re Not Being Told About the Science of Climate Change.” 

Through his position at the University of Calgary, Cooper helped facilitate fundraising for an organization called Friends of Science, which in 2014 ran a billboard in Calgary stating that “the sun is the main driver of climate change. Not You. Not CO2.”

Cooper in 2021 wrote a report for the Alberta government where he questioned whether humans are the main driver of climate change and claimed incorrectly that “there are good reasons for a decline in the plausibility of alarmist rhetoric.” 

Meta claims to be taking steps to combat misleading climate claims on its platforms, including partnering with “more than 90 independent fact-checking organizations.” The company characterizes misinformation as “false information that outside experts say undermines the existence or impacts of climate change, misrepresents scientific data and mischaracterizes mitigation and adaptation efforts.”  

Yet Meta’s enforcement of penalties against accounts that spread false claims is haphazard and lacking, CAAD argued in a report last year. Sponsoring a conservative networking event alongside Koch Industries which features a known climate denier would seem to flout the company’s policies on misinformation entirely, Buchan argues. 

“I’m kind of surprised,” he said. “To sponsor something like this so publicly seems like a reputational risk.”

Original article by Geoff Dembicki republished from DeSmog.

Continue ReadingMeta and Koch Industries to Sponsor Event Featuring Climate Denier Barry Cooper