Category: AI Artificial Intelligence

  • ‘Nice face of the devil’: Google whistleblower on AI, Gaza, and breaking NDA

    Spread the love

    Article by Evie Breese republished from openDemocracy under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International licence.

    32-year-old new mother Sophia Liguori left her AI research engineer role at Google DeepMind in protest of the firm’s products being used for AI warfare and surveillance. Image: Supplied

    Sofia Liguori tells openDemocracy about Project Nimbus and resignation that led to Google U-turn on silencing ex-staff

    The day Google DeepMind research engineer Sofia Liguori returned to work following the birth of her first child was the day her activism began. 

    The 32-year-old was part of the London-based frontier AI lab’s sustainability-focused Impact Accelerator team, tasked with identifying new ways the technology can be used for good. These range “from pathogen detection and crop resilience to medical countermeasure acceleration”, according to a LinkedIn post advertising new roles in the team.

    Liguori’s own project focused on how AI could optimise electricity power flow to allow the national grid to use less energy and reduce overall carbon emissions. She told openDemocracy she now refers to her work as “building the nice face of the devil”.

    “I felt so hypocritical that we were just talking about all these good things and not even mentioning Project Nimbus”, she said, speaking to openDemocracy from her home in south London, a Palestinian Keffiyeh scarf draped on the wall behind her. 

    Project Nimbus is a $1.2bn deal that Google and Amazon Web Services signed with Israel to build data centres in the country and provide public entities with cloud-based data storage in 2021. The contract stipulated that neither company could shut down their services in Israel or deny them to particular government entities.

    Google has said its work with Israel is “not directed at highly sensitive or classified military workloads relevant to weapons or intelligence services”, as a spokesperson told Time magazine this year. Yet training materials leaked to The Intercept in 2022 revealed the full suite of Google Cloud AI tools are available to Israeli state departments, including the Ministry of Defence, for face detection, object tracking and “sentiment analysis”. 

    The ministry could have used these tools to identify and surveil Palestinians across the West Bank, East Jerusalem, and Gaza, including since 7 October 2023, according to reporting in the New York Times and the Centre for Constitutional Rights. Israeli military officials have said they have killed 70,000 people in Gaza since the Hamas attack on October 7 2023 that killed approximately 1,200 Israelis. 

    As she sat at home with her new baby, Liguori said she “watched a live-streamed genocide for a year, knowing that my company was complicit”. She added: “If we accepted this modus operandi, we were basically legitimising what has been tested in Gaza to become the standard.”

    Returning to work in August last year, she said she implored her colleagues: “If our aim is AI for good, trying to stop genocide is one of the ultimate goods we can do, right?”

    Ultimately, having been unable to convince executives to end Google’s role in Israeli military actions, Liguori left the company this year. In recent weeks, she has acted as a whistleblower, speaking out despite being subject to the strict lifetime non-disparagement agreement signed by Google employees.

    Liguroi had always been prepared to be fired for her activism, but, she said, the real risk of “being sued by Google is different”. The tech giant’s parent company, Alphabet, is consistently ranked as the third or fourth most valuable globally, with a reported market worth of around $3.5trn.  

    This week, she was delivered some good news: a Google executive told the company’s UK staff that it will not enforce the NDA’s clause against workers who criticise the company after leaving. Speaking to openDemocracy after the news was announced, Liguori details what it took to get Google to back down.

    The final straw

    Liguori, whose background is in theoretical physics and reinforcement learning for video games, told openDemocracy she never set out to work with frontier AI models and knew “nothing” about Project Nimbus when she joined Google DeepMind in May 2023. 

    After becoming increasingly aware of the project’s impact in Gaza while on maternity leave, Liguori sent her immediate colleagues a letter urging them to take action shortly after she returned to work in August last year.

    “This team is full of mothers,” she wrote. “I am not going to describe how it feels to become a mother for the first time while watching snipers targeting children, children dying of starvation, and all the rest of the horrors. What’s happening is lacerating my heart, really.”

    The letter, which openDemocracy has seen, continues: “How can we do AI for good, and not even talk about Project Nimbus? How can we do AI for good in a company that is officially recognised and listed [as] complicit in the ongoing genocide in Palestine?”

    Liguori also asked to discuss Nimbus in a team meeting. When her request was denied by a senior manager, she began sharing links to news articles about the project in internal channels. If they contained the word “genocide”, she said, they were deleted for “violating internal policies” prohibiting “aggressive language”. 

    Two months after her return to work, documents were leaked to Israeli-Palestinian publication +972 Magazine and Hebrew-language outlet Local Call revealing that Google and Amazon had agreed to use a secret code to “effectively sidestep legal obligations” and tip off the Israeli government if they were ever ordered to share Israeli data shared on their cloud services with law enforcement authorities any where in the world.

    Then, in late April 2026, it was announced that Google had signed a contract with the US Department of War that would allow the Pentagon to use Google’s AI for “any lawful government purpose”, including mission planning and weapons targeting. 

    That was the day Liguori decided enough was enough. The petition she and over 600 colleagues had sent to CEO Sundar Pichai opposing the partnership had fallen on deaf ears.  

    “I really believe there is a value of infighting from the inside,” she said, “I tried to stay and do activism and raise awareness”, but the mental toll was becoming too great. “I reached a level of disgust with my company that was just incompatible with me continuing to stay there.” 

    Liguori used a combination of sick and holiday leave to cease undertaking work for Google, officially resigning on 20 October. 

    “I no longer believe that our technology will have a net positive impact on society. I think there’s a fantasy world where AI can help decarbonise grids, cut waste, protect ecosystems, and benefit humanity,” she wrote in her publicly posted resignation letter. 

    “But it’s not this world, and it’s not this type of general-purpose AI we are racing to develop.”

    The growing revolt inside Google DeepMind

    Google hasn’t always been so resistant to employee dissent. 

    Back in 2018, after 3,000 employees signed a petition seeking a policy that would stop Google and its contractors from “ever building warfare technology”, the tech firm announced that it would no longer be renewing its contract with the Pentagon on controversial military drone Project Maven. 

    Shortly after, the company published its AI Principles, a set of internal guidelines that prohibited the use of its technology for AI weapons or for human rights abuses.

    But weeks after Donald Trump’s second term began in January last year, the Silicon Valley-based company appeared to have a change of heart, with the AI principles updated to remove references to weapons or surveillance. 

    “We believe democracies should lead in AI development, guided by core values like freedom, equality, and respect for human rights,” Google DeepMind chief Demis Hassabis and research labs senior vice president James Manyika wrote in a blog post announcing the updated policy.

    Soon after, Google announced that Gemini would be used for both classified and unclassified purposes at the AI factory of Lockheed Martin, a US weapons company that primarily builds military aircraft, missiles, satellites, and defence technology for the US armed forces. 

    Then, in June of this year, a partnership between Google and US military contractor Palantir was expanded to integrate Palantir platforms across Google Cloud and Google Cloud Marketplace. 

    “You never know then how your technology will be used in Palantir’s systems,” Liguori told openDemocracy. “Workers need to know what the technology they are building on will contribute, and we want the right to abstain on ethical grounds”.

    Since then, a number of UK Googlers have left the company on ethical grounds, but were gagged from speaking about the firm by strict NDAs. Feeling strongly that the public needed to know about Google’s dealings with Israel, Liguori said she decided to breach her own NDA to publish her resignation letter, knowing that Google could retaliate. 

    But this week Google told its staff in the UK that it will not take legal action against those who criticise the company or its AI products after leaving. “We’ve always encouraged an open dialogue about safety and responsibility,” a Google spokesperson told The Washington Post. “Recently, we’ve updated our terms for new hires, which included removing the post-termination aspect of non-disparagement clauses.”

    Liguori sees the move as a win that “happened because of collective action”. After an employee’s attempts to raise concerns about the clause through internal channels did not lead to any change, DeepMind members of the United Tech and Allied Workers (UTAW) coordinated with the No Tech for Apartheid campaign group and whistleblowing non-profit Psst to pressure Google from multiple directions, Liguori told openDemocracy. 

    It’s only because of this support network that Liguori says she was able to “find the courage to take the risk” of a public resignation.

    The concession comes as the Employment Rights Act 2025 comes into effect in the UK, allowing unions to enter workplaces across the country to speak to workers in person about joining a union. At Google and Google DeepMind, the new law will likely support UTAW and Unite’s drive for formal recognition.

    For Liguori, who joked that she had considered “disappearing in the Italian countryside”, the news that she won’t face legal action for her activism has come as a “big relief”. She added: “… it’s also a sign that our collective effort had an effect, and that it’s worth challenging the rules.”

    Google has not responded to openDemocracy’s request for comment at time of publication.

    Article by Evie Breese republished from openDemocracy under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial 4.0 International licence.

  • Lobbyists should not be in the driving seat when it comes to data centres and AI

    Spread the love

    A report published this week shows that AI lobbyists have had an huge and unequal access to government over the last two years compared to any others. 84% of ministerial stakeholder meetings on data centres were with business or private-sector trade associations whereas ministers met with no environmental NGOs and not a single community group prior to designation of an AI Growth Zone.

    The report comes as questions remain about the protections for water, energy and climate impacts contained in Chancellor John Healey’s announcement of a data centre covenant which was broadly welcomed by the AI industry in a context of escalating opposition to data centres across the UK.

    Rachel MiIlward, deputy leader of the Green Party of England and Wales. Image under Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication by RandomCommons by Stuff via wikimedia.
    Rachel MiIlward, deputy leader of the Green Party of England and Wales. CC image.

    Rachel Millward, Green Party Deputy Leader said:

    “Labour is diving headfirst into AI without a roadmap, charmed by corporate lobbyists while community and green voices are shut out. We need to slam the brakes on new data centres before they drain our water supplies and wreck the UK’s carbon budget. 

    “When policy is written by corporations, decisions benefit shareholder profits rather than the public good. It’s a dangerous lack of oversight, proven by a recent FOI showing the government doesn’t even know what current data centres are being used for.”

    Report authors Spotlight on Corruption also highlight that not a single environmental group sits on the government’s AI Energy Council even though the group has a mandate “to support the use of sustainable energy to power AI” and that the group met only once in the 17 months from its establishment in January 2025 to July 2026.

  • End tax relief for datacentres to fund energy bill support this winter, say Greens ahead of Budget

    Spread the love
    Green party leader Zack Polanski (Green Party of England and Wales). Image: Bristol Green Party Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication.
    Green party leader Zack Polanski (Green Party of England and Wales). Image: Bristol Green Party Creative Commons CC0 1.0 Universal Public Domain Dedication.
    • Greens call on government to remove datacentres from full expensing tax relief scheme to bring forward an additional £5 billion in corporation tax across 2027-2029
    • They say this could be used to increase the Warm Homes Discount by up to £500 for those with highest energy needs 
    • Leader Polanski says the government should be prioritising lowering bills over handouts for big tech at Autumn Budget next week

    The Green Party has called on the government to end certain tax reliefs for datacentres and use the money to fund support for energy bills this winter, as households are expected to see bills rise by over £271 in January – the biggest jump in four years.

    The Greens say that by removing datacentres from ‘full expensing’ tax relief, the Treasury could bring forward an additional £5 billion extra in corporation tax across 2027-2029. This could be used to increase the Warm Homes Discount from £150 to up to £650 to support 5.6 million households facing a spike in their energy bills. 

    There are currently around 500 datacentres in the UK but their number is expected to expand by more than a third. Last week, the Chief Executive of Ofgem warned that datacentres could push up household energy bills even further. 

    Earlier this year the Green Party called for an immediate end to the blanket designation of new datacentres as ‘critical infrastructure’ and tighter planning rules to prevent a rash of new datacentres taking precedence over households for water and energy usage.

    Green Party leader Zack Polanski said: 

    “Right now the government is allowing big tech giants and energy-guzzling datacentres to kick their tax obligations down the road while families are being stretched to breaking point by ever-rising energy bills. 

    “This is wrong. The government’s priority at the Budget next week should be supporting families this winter as temperatures drop and bills spike. 

    “Ending full expensing tax relief for datacentres would free up £5 billion – money that could be used to fund immediate support for households struggling with their energy bills.” 

    This is part of a broader package of measures the Green Party are calling for at the Autumn Budget, which they say could raise over £60 billion to fund urgent cost of living measures. The Green Party Leadership, MPs and Peers have today written to the Chancellor laying out their full proposals, which include: 

    • Aligning rates of Capital Gains Tax with Income Tax and closing loopholes, to raise an additional £19.7 billion annually by 2030. 
    • Applying National Insurance to investment income, in line with employment income, to raise at least £6.1 billion per year.
    • Introducing an annual wealth tax of 1% on assets over £10 million, and 2% over £1 billion, to raise at least £14.8 billion. 
    • Introducing a proper windfall tax of 38% on the UK’s biggest banks, to raise at least £19 billion. 
    • Ending tax breaks to fossil fuel producers to raise £2.7 billion. 
    • Introduce a three-year emergency brake on rents and lifting the freeze on Local Housing Allowance which would cost £2 billion a year by 2030. 
    • Funding free bus travel for under 22s in England costing £1.9 billion a year.
    • Extend free school meals to all primary and secondary school children to help with food cost inflation costing around £1.5 billion per year 
  • UK government met 137 businesses over AI datacentres – but no environmental groups

    Spread the love

    https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/oct/27/uk-government-environmental-groups-ai-datacentres-expansion-plans-investigation

    Members of the Save Brick Lane campaign protested against the construction of an AI datacentre in the east London neighbourhood in June. Photograph: David Levene/The Guardia

    Investigation finds dozens of ministers and civil servants moved into AI roles as government developed datacentre expansion plans

    The UK’s policy on datacentres and AI was developed without any meetings with environmental groups, an investigation has found.

    The nonprofit organisation Spotlight on Corruption said a “considerable revolving door” shaped the government’s development of “AI growth zones”, a central plank of the former prime minister Keir Starmer’s AI and economic policy, with 38 ministers, senior civil servants and special advisers hired to positions in AI companies between July 2024 and September 2026.

    Meanwhile, even as top officials left government for jobs at OpenAI and Anthropic, government departments largely failed to engage meaningfully with stakeholders outside the technology industry.

    Kamila Kingstone, a campaign lead at the NGO, said: “The government totally failed at the most senior level to speak to environmental NGOs or community groups when developing its flagship policy on AI datacentres. This is despite the serious environmental implications of its plans.”

    Over 12 months, Spotlight on Corruption filed 40 freedom of information requests to 18 government agencies, seeking details of meetings and investment figures relating to the government’s policymaking on the growth zones, covering the period between July 2024 and June 2026.

    …

    https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2026/oct/27/uk-government-environmental-groups-ai-datacentres-expansion-plans-investigation

  • ‘Pure arrogance’: anger in Finland as Google illegally fells 250,000 trees for datacentre

    Spread the love

    https://www.theguardian.com/environment/ng-interactive/2026/oct/22/finland-google-felling-trees-datacentre

    Google has illegally stripped the entire area, removing even the top soil. Photograph: Jarno Artika/The Guardian

    Company ordered to stop work at two sites in country, which has found itself at forefront of tech firms’ latest push

    Behind a wire fence lies a vast gaping wound of earth. Before Google’s arrival a few months ago, an estimated quarter of a million trees occupied the 330 hectares (815 acres) of forest near the town of Muhos in rural northern Finland. Now they are all gone.

    After the tech company illegally stripped the entire area to build a datacentre – taking even the top soil with it – all that remains is a vast expanse of mud indented with the trail marks of machinery, puddles and mounds of earth, roots and branches. Residents say that brown water flowing off the site is going into a stream that feeds the Oulujoki River.

    “It doesn’t end. It goes on and on,” says Mari Annala, an ecologist from the Finnish Association for Nature Conservation (SLL), looking at drone footage of the former forest from the perimeter.

    Earlier this month, Google was ordered by the Finnish Licensing and Supervision Authority (LVV) to temporarily stop work on Muhos and another site about 100km south-east in the village of Otanmäki after it failed to complete the necessary environmental impact assessments before clearcutting the land. The news has prompted widespread outcry and a national reckoning over what role, if any, the country should play in the global rush to build datacentres to keep up with rapid AI development.

    Last week, Google’s Finland country manager, Antti Järvinen, apologised for the forest clearings but claimed the company had acted “on the best understanding we had of the legislation at the time”.

    …

    Continues at https://www.theguardian.com/environment/ng-interactive/2026/oct/22/finland-google-felling-trees-datacentre