“It’s up to all of us”: British doctor shares why he is on Global Sumud Flotilla

Spread the love

Original article by Ana Vračar republished from peoples dispatch under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 (CC BY-SA) license.

Supporters gather in Barcelona to see of the Sumud Freedom Flotilla to Gaza. Photo: Podemos / X

British doctor James Smith tells People’s Health Dispatch why he is joining the Global Sumud Flotilla and why health workers must organize against Israel’s genocide.

Health workers are among the dozens preparing to join the Global Sumud Flotilla, setting sail in the first week of September from ports in Tunisia, Spain, and Italy to break Israel’s blockade of Gaza. As at least 50 ships get ready to cross the Mediterranean, People’s Health Dispatch spoke with Dr. James Smith, a British doctor and health activist with Medact and the People’s Health Movement (PHM). Having volunteered in Gaza during the genocide – and repeatedly blocked from returning by Israeli authorities – Smith now continues his solidarity work through the Flotilla’s latest launch.

People’s Health Dispatch: To start, could you briefly introduce yourself? What do you do, and how did you decide to join the Global Sumud Flotilla?

James Smith: I’m a doctor trained in the UK, and for most of the past decade I’ve worked on and off in the international medical humanitarian sector with various organizations. During that time, I’ve also maintained a strong interest in health justice and solidarity movements, and I’ve always followed the work of the People’s Health Movement (PHM).

I foremost came to connect with the Global Sumud Flotilla, I guess, because I worked in Gaza during the genocide. I spent about two and a half months there as an emergency doctor, and what I witnessed made it very clear how limited humanitarianism and the liberal political order really are. It’s clear in Gaza, as it should be in many other parts of the world, that we can’t rely on existing political or legal systems to uphold justice, fairness, or equality. Unfortunately, that responsibility often falls to ordinary folks.

We’ve seen this for decades, almost a century, in international solidarity movements around Palestine. More recently, there’s been a vibrant resurgence of direct actiondockworkers refusing to load military equipment directed to Israel and campaigns against the international arms trade in the UK and elsewhere. And, of course, we’ve seen the flotillas. They have existed since the 2000s: the Freedom Flotilla Coalition has organized more than 30 missions, but this is the biggest single international flotilla effort so far.

For me, as someone who has worked in Gaza, who has lobbied politicians, spoken to the media, and written in academic forums, there’s nothing else to do. It feels like every other avenue has already been tried. Nothing has worked. That’s why I believe it’s up to all of us – as citizens of the world, if I can use that phrase – to take action and force an end to Israel’s genocide, because that’s the only way it will happen. We need to be very aware that humanitarianism can’t solve a genocide. James Orbinski said this back in 1999, humanitarianism alone cannot stop genocide, it cannot stop atrocity crimes. So while I’ve been rejected from returning to Gaza, I also recognize that humanitarianism isn’t the answer. That’s one of the reasons why I’m joining the flotilla.

PHD: We’ve seen health workers in Gaza murdered, kidnapped, imprisoned, and tortured. As a health worker yourself – and perhaps in conversations with others joining the Flotilla – what is the driving motivation? What do you most want to raise, given the systematic attacks on Gaza’s health system, and more broadly on Palestine’s healthcare, including in the occupied West Bank?

JS: We’ve seen an unprecedented assault on health as part of the strategy of genocide. Approximately 1,600 Palestinian healthcare workers have been killed. The entire healthcare system, its infrastructure, its medical supplies, has been devastated.

I personally visited hospitals across Gaza, from north to south, all of which had suffered targeted attacks. Bullet holes in the walls. Generators destroyed by Israeli tanks. Whole wards shelled by artillery. At one hospital in Khan Younis, after Israeli soldiers occupied the building, they cut every single ultrasound probe before leaving. We’re seeing a meticulous, systematic assault on health as a way to ethnically cleanse and eliminate the Palestinian people.

Read more: Israeli destruction of Gaza’s healthcare is a blueprint for future imperialist wars

Even if this were not the case, as healthcare workers we have a responsibility that goes beyond treating the immediate pathologies that walk through the door. We also have to address the root causes of ill health, which always come back to justice, discrimination, and different forms of oppression – factors that shape how we live and relate to one another. For me, it’s a moral, professional, and political responsibility to engage in this work. And while I’ve had the privilege of working alongside many Palestinian health workers, I believe even those who haven’t shared this obligation, it is incumbent on us to resist what Israel is doing in Palestine.

PHD: To conclude, what can people who are not on the Flotilla do to support it? What should they prioritize over the next couple of weeks?

JS: The simple reality is that we live within a capitalist global order, and therefore some of our power lies in where we put our money. Francesca Albanese has published a report listing many corporations and institutions complicit in the genocide, those bankrolling it and profiting from it. One of the lowest bars for action, in this context, is to think carefully and ethically about where we spend our money. We must engage in the boycott, divestment, and sanctions (BDS) movement: boycott through our own purchasing choices, ensure our loved ones are also doing the same, and collectively support these efforts.

PHD: What kind of collective actions do you see as most urgent?

JS: Coordinated collective direct action is crucial: lobbying political powers to cut ties with Israel, impose sanctions, and sever economic, political, and diplomatic relationships. And we must ensure these ties aren’t reintroduced the moment a ceasefire is agreed.

In my lifetime, I’ve never seen this level of mobilization in support of Palestine. There’s been a real revival of the solidarity movement, but we still need to organize more coherently within our workplaces, friendship groups, and families. Even after two years of genocide, there is still so much work to do. As healthcare workers, we need to organize more cohesively. And these mobilizations must be sustained not just for days, weeks, or months, but for years and decades, in pursuit of a liberated Palestine.

The Sumud Flotilla is a privilege to be part of, but many people following Israel’s genocide might feel frustrated that they can’t do something, let’s say, physically. But there is always something to do, wherever we are in the world, from the remotest corners to towns and cities right next to Palestine. We need to build connections to sustain these movements and sustain each other. And we must recognize that all of these actions are interconnected: choosing not to buy an Israeli product, choosing a Palestinian one instead, or booking travel through a platform that doesn’t operate in the occupied West Bank. Each of these small acts is part of a wider movement for liberation.

Interview slightly edited for length

People’s Health Dispatch is a fortnightly bulletin published by the People’s Health Movement and Peoples Dispatch. For more articles and to subscribe to People’s Health Dispatch, click here.

Original article by Ana Vračar republished from peoples dispatch under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 (CC BY-SA) license.

Experiencing issues with this image not appearing. I suspect because it's so critical of Zionist Keir Starmer's support of and complicity in Israel's genocides.
Genocide denier and Current UK Prime Minister Keir Starmer is quoted that he supports Zionism without qualification. He also confirms that UK air force support has been essential in Israel’s mass-murdering genocide. Includes URLs https://www.declassifieduk.org/keir-starmers-100-spy-flights-over-gaza-in-support-of-israel/ and https://youtu.be/O74hZCKKdpA
UK Labour Party government ministers Keir Starmer, Angela Rayner and Rachel Reeves explain that they are partners complicit in Israel's Gaza genocide. The UK has provided Israel with arms, military and air force support. They explain that they don't do gas chambers but do do forced marches, starvation, destroy hospitals, mass-murders of journalists and healthcare workers.
UK Labour Party government ministers Keir Starmer, Angela Rayner and Rachel Reeves explain that they are partners complicit in Israel’s Gaza genocide. The UK has provided Israel with arms, military and air force support. They explain that they don’t do gas chambers but do do forced marches, starvation, destroy hospitals, mass-murders of journalists and healthcare workers.
Vote Labour for Genocide.
Vote Labour for Genocide.

Continue Reading“It’s up to all of us”: British doctor shares why he is on Global Sumud Flotilla

Campaigners in the UK say get Palantir out of the NHS

Spread the love

Original article by Ana Vračar republished from peoples dispatch under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 (CC BY-SA) license.

Source: Talia Woodin/Medact

Health workers and activists ramp up their campaign to oppose surveillance company Palantir’s role in managing NHS data

Health workers and activists in Britain are intensifying their campaign against US-based surveillance and data company Palantir, as Keir Starmer’s government accelerates its push to involve the notorious firm in managing National Health Service (NHS) data.

Palantir first gained a foothold in the NHS during the COVID-19 pandemic, securing contracts outside standard procurement processes and enjoying popularity among high-ranking health officials. The company, infamous for its involvement in operations such as the US-led invasions of Afghanistan and Iraq and migrant persecution under the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), soon expanded its role in Britain. By last year, it had won a £330 million (USD 417 million) contract to implement the Federated Data Platform (FDP), intended to modernize medical data management across England.

Not all NHS institutions are currently able to share data because of differing systems. Both Conservative and Labour governments have identified this as the main reason for bottlenecks in the health system and claimed that resolving the problem would lead to improvements to care. However, organizations like Medact, Just Treatment, and Corporate Watch warn that entrusting this task to Palantir could deepen issues rather than solve them.

Similarly, many health experts have highlighted how the FDP would effectively lock the NHS into dependency on Palantir. The company’s systems are designed in a way to make data extraction difficult and integration with industry-standard analytics costly and complicated, so users are compelled to keep using them. “Palantir’s system pushes people to its own proprietary systems; and switching costs [for the NHS] will be very high,” Doctors’ Association and Foxglove warned in a 2023 report.

The current government is pushing forward with this form of private sector expansion in the NHS despite warnings from trusts and experts that the results will fall far short of expectations. In fact, some NHS organizations being forced to adopt the FDP under Labour’s administration have said that the new platform could result in a loss of functionality compared to the systems they currently rely on.

Read more: Labour considers expanding private sector role in NHS, undermining the already fragile public health system

While there is general agreement among analysts that data sharing and usage within the NHS could be significantly improved, they argue that these improvements can and should be achieved through local and regional initiatives. In contrast to the top-down model ushered in by the FDP, these initiatives would build on existing systems and expertise, avoiding handing over control to a private company with a track record of human rights abuses.

Concerns that the FDP could make the NHS entirely dependent on Palantir are sharpened by fears over how patient data might be used. As one of the world’s largest public healthcare systems, the NHS holds an unique health dataset. While such data has immense potential to strengthen public services, entrusting it to corporate partners poses great risks. For instance, it could be exploited for purposes such as tracking and criminalizing migrants—a practice that has been systematically pursued under Britain’s hostile environment policies.

Read more: Should health workers work with counter terrorism agencies?

Palantir takes pride in finding new applications for data, specifically to reinforce Western dominance. Given that the full scope of the FDP remains unclear, there is significant concern that NHS data could also be exploited to boost Palantir’s surveillance tools. These tools are already being deployed in Israel’s ongoing genocide against Palestinians in the Gaza Strip.

Palantir’s leadership has been outspoken in its support for Israel, openly aligning with Benjamin Netanyahu’s government even as it proceeded to kill tens of thousands of Palestinians. The company is actively testing—or rather, showcasing—its artificial intelligence (AI) models through Israel’s attacks in Palestine and Lebanon. This indicates a clear intent to monetize these tools further by marketing them to other states preparing to go on killing sprees.

Handing over NHS medical data to Palantir would deepen the Starmer administration’s complicity in Israel’s war crimes, health justice organizations warn. Such a move risks staining the NHS’s reputation, turning its dataset into a tool for oppression internationally while undermining public trust in the healthcare system at home.

Many had hoped that a change in government in July would mean an end to the FDP. However, “instead of hitting reset, Labour hit accelerate,” Just Treatment remarked during a No Palantir in the NHS meeting in November. This response reflects Labour’s priorities when it comes to the public healthcare provider. “If the government were setting out to implement reforms in the way that our data is held to improve health outcomes and improve the NHS, they would be going about it in a way that maximizes public trust, maximizes public and health service and health worker support for those initiatives,” the organization remarked during the meeting.

Instead, the government appears more interested in using national health data for economic gain. This approach aligns closely with recommendations from neoliberal policy advisors, such as those at the Tony Blair Institute for Global Change, who have recently called for the use of NHS data as a means to boost Britain’s economic standing.

Although the implementation of the FDP is progressing, activists argue that it is not too late to stop it—especially if local groups escalate their efforts. They emphasize that by increasing pressure, health workers and activists could not only push for the cancellation of Palantir’s FDP contract but also demand the termination of all agreements with companies complicit in Israel’s occupation. While Palantir is currently a key focus, the organizations highlighted that this campaign is just the beginning, serving as a starting point for broader action.

Original article by Ana Vračar republished from peoples dispatch under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 (CC BY-SA) license.

Continue ReadingCampaigners in the UK say get Palantir out of the NHS